This thread's purpose is to decide who is the best mafia player in Mafia games. This is the person that noticeably enjoys being a part of a team and stands out in it, working as a reference to his peers: the name to be feared.
Vandred. [9]
Imperium. [5]
Demonspeed. [4]
Juviii. [4]
Evil3ye. [3]
desin24. [2]
Farfalla. [2]
GB. [2]
Lady pompom. [2]
SonOfDaws. [2]
Gajeel. [1]
Sakura Taichou. [1]
Shad. [1]
digitaldude. [0]
GrySun. [0]
Hardy. [0]
Shobu_Yoruichi. [0]
Demonspeed.
desin24.
digitaldude.
Evil3ye.
Farfalla.
Gajeel.
GB.
GrySun.
Hardy.
Imperium.
Juviii.
Lady pompom.
Sakura Taichou.
Shad.
Shobu_Yoruichi.
SonOfDaws.
Vandred.
Remember that this event is for fun purposes. As always, keep the tone friendly and respectful.
To view the rules and general info about the Awards, click [HERE].
@Juviii - just look at Guilty Gear game. Or actually, don't. It's painful to see.
@Evil3ye - only mafia once this year I think, but he plays the alignment pretty well from what I can see.
@SonOfDaws - I think he's a better mafia than TP, mainly due to the team-aspect that most TP roles lack, which he does quite well in. Not sure if in a lead or assisting position but impressive nonetheless.
Couple of basic stats* here before evaluations. *All numbers including substitudes.
We have 7 players have been Mafia 3x in the last eleven (27%). Most notably here Shobu, who played 3 total games in total in this period and was Mafia each time, having a 100% Mafia rate.
Player
Mafia
Town
Third Party
Total
Mafia
percentage
Townie
percentage
Third Party
percentage
Shobu_Yoruichi
3
3
100%
0%
0%
Lady pompom
3
3
6
50%
50%
0%
Shad
3
4
7
43%
57%
0%
desin24
3
5
8
38%
63%
0%
James Rye
3
4
1
8
38%
50%
13%
Demonspeed
3
5
1
9
33%
56%
11%
digitaldude
3
7
1
11
27%
64%
9%
Player
Game #
Theme
Primary Role
Secondary Role
Time of outcome
Player-outcome
Player-Faction-outcome
Demonspeed
90
Guilty Gear -Strive-
Mafia Apprentice
03 Day
lynched
victorious
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Robber
05 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Detective
Illusion
04 Day/03 Night
hostkilled
defeated
desin24
90
Guilty Gear -Strive-
Mafia Noble
04 Day
lynched
victorious
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Escort (I)
06 Day
lynched
defeated
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Detective
01 Night
killed
defeated
digitaldude
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Member (I)
02 Day
killed
defeated
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Janitor
04 Day
lynched
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Member
Noble
05 Day
hostkilled/replaced
victorious
James Rye
91
Moon Banket - Food Wars
Mafia Detective
05 Day
lynched
defeated
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Janitor (I)
02 Day
lynched
defeated
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Escort
07 Day
lynched
defeated
Lady pompom
92
Kingdom Rush
Mafia Detective
Dodger
04 Day
lost
defeated
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Boss (I)
Sickly Townie
05 Day
lynched
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Member
Noble
05 Night
won
victorious
Shad
90
Guilty Gear -Strive-
Mafia Boss
02 Day
killed
victorious
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Doctor (I)
03 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Boss
Mafia Mason
05 Day
lynched
defeated
Shobu_Yoruichi
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Detective (II)
Prosecutor
04 Day
killed
victorious
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Detective (II)
04 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Boss
06 Day
lynched
defeated
10 players have been Mafia 2x in the last eleven (18%). Gryffindor played 2total games in total in this period and was Mafia each time, having a 100% Mafia rate.
Player
Mafia
Town
Third Party
Total
Mafia
percentage
Townie
percentage
Third Party
percentage
Gryffindor
2
2
100%
0%
0%
Hardy
2
1
1
4
50%
25%
25%
Vandred
2
2
4
50%
50%
0%
Brandish µ
2
2
1
5
40%
40%
20%
GB
2
4
6
33%
67%
0%
Gajeel
2
4
1
7
29%
57%
14%
Sakura Taichou
2
4
1
7
29%
57%
14%
MarmaladeSky
2
6
8
25%
75%
0%
SirSamuel016
2
5
1
8
25%
63%
13%
GrySun
2
6
1
9
22%
67%
11%
Player
Game #
Theme
Primary Role
Secondary Role
Time of outcome
Player-outcome
Player-Faction-outcome
Brandish µ
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Member (II)/Sleeper
Traitor-Naive
05 Night
killed
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Janitor
Healthy Townie
02 Day
killed
victorious
Gajeel
87
Baccano!
Mafia Detective
05 Day
lynched
defeated
89
Mafia Jump - OMO weekly
Mafia Assassin
05 Day
won
victorious
GB
92
Kingdom Rush
Mafia Diffuser
Sickly Townie
02 Day
killed
defeated
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Escort (II)
07 Day
won
victorious
Gryffindor
91
Moon Banket - Food Wars
Mafia Pirate
06 Day
lynched
defeated
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Poisoner (I)
04 Day
lynched
defeated
GrySun
89
Mafia Jump - OMO weekly
Mafia Member/Paranoid Detective
Traitor-Sane
05 Day
won
victorious
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Detective (I)
01 Night
killed
defeated
Hardy
87
Baccano!
Mafia Apprentice
03 Day
lynched
defeated
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Member (III)
05 Night
killed
defeated
MarmaladeSky
92
Kingdom Rush
Mafia Escort
Restless Spirit
01 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Boss
Mafia Mason
02 Day
lynched
defeated
Sakura Taichou
87
Baccano!
Mafia Burden
06 Day
hostkilled
defeated
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Boss (I)
01 Day
lynched
defeated
SirSamuel016
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Poisoner (II)
05 Day
lynched
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Escort
Sickly Townie
03 Night
killed
victorious
Vandred
87
Baccano!
Mafia Escort
06 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Member/Recruiting Mason
Illusion/Traitor-Sane
10 Night
lost
defeated
17 further players have been Mafia 1x in the last eleven (9%). Notable here the returning players Faust, Hermit, Imperium as well as Organizized (unrecruited Sane Traitor) played as mafia in their retunring debute game, as have Slaynoir and Cinera in their very first game.
Couple of basic stats* here before evaluations. *All numbers including substitudes.
We have 7 players have been Mafia 3x in the last eleven (27%). Most notably here Shobu, who played 3 total games in total in this period and was Mafia each time, having a 100% Mafia rate.
Player
Mafia
Town
Third Party
Total
Mafia
percentage
Townie
percentage
Third Party
percentage
Shobu_Yoruichi
3
3
100%
0%
0%
Lady pompom
3
3
6
50%
50%
0%
Shad
3
4
7
43%
57%
0%
desin24
3
5
8
38%
63%
0%
James Rye
3
4
1
8
38%
50%
13%
Demonspeed
3
5
1
9
33%
56%
11%
digitaldude
3
7
1
11
27%
64%
9%
Player
Game #
Theme
Primary Role
Secondary Role
Time of outcome
Player-outcome
Player-Faction-outcome
Demonspeed
90
Guilty Gear -Strive-
Mafia Apprentice
03 Day
lynched
victorious
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Robber
05 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Detective
Illusion
04 Day/03 Night
hostkilled
defeated
desin24
90
Guilty Gear -Strive-
Mafia Noble
04 Day
lynched
victorious
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Escort (I)
06 Day
lynched
defeated
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Detective
01 Night
killed
defeated
digitaldude
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Member (I)
02 Day
killed
defeated
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Janitor
04 Day
lynched
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Member
Noble
05 Day
hostkilled/replaced
victorious
James Rye
91
Moon Banket - Food Wars
Mafia Detective
05 Day
lynched
defeated
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Janitor (I)
02 Day
lynched
defeated
95
Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac
Mafia Escort
07 Day
lynched
defeated
Lady pompom
92
Kingdom Rush
Mafia Detective
Dodger
04 Day
lost
defeated
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Boss (I)
Sickly Townie
05 Day
lynched
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Member
Noble
05 Night
won
victorious
Shad
90
Guilty Gear -Strive-
Mafia Boss
02 Day
killed
victorious
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Doctor (I)
03 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Boss
Mafia Mason
05 Day
lynched
defeated
Shobu_Yoruichi
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Detective (II)
Prosecutor
04 Day
killed
victorious
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Detective (II)
04 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Boss
06 Day
lynched
defeated
10 players have been Mafia 2x in the last eleven (18%). Gryffindor played 2total games in total in this period and was Mafia each time, having a 100% Mafia rate.
Player
Mafia
Town
Third Party
Total
Mafia
percentage
Townie
percentage
Third Party
percentage
Gryffindor
2
2
100%
0%
0%
Hardy
2
1
1
4
50%
25%
25%
Vandred
2
2
4
50%
50%
0%
Brandish µ
2
2
1
5
40%
40%
20%
GB
2
4
6
33%
67%
0%
Gajeel
2
4
1
7
29%
57%
14%
Sakura Taichou
2
4
1
7
29%
57%
14%
MarmaladeSky
2
6
8
25%
75%
0%
SirSamuel016
2
5
1
8
25%
63%
13%
GrySun
2
6
1
9
22%
67%
11%
Player
Game #
Theme
Primary Role
Secondary Role
Time of outcome
Player-outcome
Player-Faction-outcome
Brandish µ
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Member (II)/Sleeper
Traitor-Naive
05 Night
killed
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Janitor
Healthy Townie
02 Day
killed
victorious
Gajeel
87
Baccano!
Mafia Detective
05 Day
lynched
defeated
89
Mafia Jump - OMO weekly
Mafia Assassin
05 Day
won
victorious
GB
92
Kingdom Rush
Mafia Diffuser
Sickly Townie
02 Day
killed
defeated
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Escort (II)
07 Day
won
victorious
Gryffindor
91
Moon Banket - Food Wars
Mafia Pirate
06 Day
lynched
defeated
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Poisoner (I)
04 Day
lynched
defeated
GrySun
89
Mafia Jump - OMO weekly
Mafia Member/Paranoid Detective
Traitor-Sane
05 Day
won
victorious
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Detective (I)
01 Night
killed
defeated
Hardy
87
Baccano!
Mafia Apprentice
03 Day
lynched
defeated
94
Magi: The Crests of Magic
Mafia Member (III)
05 Night
killed
defeated
MarmaladeSky
92
Kingdom Rush
Mafia Escort
Restless Spirit
01 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Boss
Mafia Mason
02 Day
lynched
defeated
Sakura Taichou
87
Baccano!
Mafia Burden
06 Day
hostkilled
defeated
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Boss (I)
01 Day
lynched
defeated
SirSamuel016
93
My Hero Academia - The Burning Building Mission
Mafia Poisoner (II)
05 Day
lynched
defeated
96
Civilization
Mafia Escort
Sickly Townie
03 Night
killed
victorious
Vandred
87
Baccano!
Mafia Escort
06 Day
lynched
defeated
97
Omoneko: Answer Arc
Mafia Member/Recruiting Mason
Illusion/Traitor-Sane
10 Night
lost
defeated
17 further players have been Mafia 1x in the last eleven (9%). Notable here the returning players Faust, Hermit, Imperium as well as Organizized (unrecruited Sane Traitor) played as mafia in their retunring debute game, as have Slaynoir and Cinera in their very first game.
Farfalla was the brains of the Magi game team I was in, got investigated unfortunately. She shot me to recruit D1 as Assassin, that's gotta be a record.
@desin24 for fighting all the way to the end during the BnHA game @Vandred for the amazing fight he fought during the omoneko game @Gajeel for his assassin victory (with Gry)
There's been an update to our forum rules to broaden crediting/sourcing to all series news/announcement, etc. Please read HERE
Oscars Contest 2023 is LIVE! Click HERE for a chance to win your Oscar!
It's back! MH presents a celebration of manga/anime culture; Mangahelpers Awards 2022 is NOW LIVE!
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
