Voting Best Overall Seinen

[Josef]

I nominate Eden: It's an Endless World, Ryuuguuden and Music of Marie.

 

[MattC302]

I nominate Tekkon Kinkreet.

 

[Nii]

Wait, no one's nominated a certain little masterpiece yet? I nominate Mushishi

 

[0Xellos]

Kingdom all the way

 

[perspherspley]

I'll nominate Kingdom, and Until Death Do Us Part(Shi ga Futari o Wakatsu Made).

 

[NibbPower]

I support Berserk.

 

[MiyamotoMusashi]

Many great titles have already been nominated, so i go with Sanctuary, Blade of the Immortal and REAL

 

[zelllogan]

I support Kingdom. It's my favourite manga right now. It's epic & not too sad/depressing like Berserk.
I won't participate much in this seinen awards because I would just nominate Kingdom in almost all categories.

I also nominate 20th century boys & Homonculus.

The first one got the best scenario & Naoki Urasawa might be the greatest mangaka (Pluto, Monster, 20th century boys, Billy Bat). Most mangaka got one or two great mangas, Naoki got at least 4.

Homonculus was one of the weirdest thing I read in my life but it worked. It was a great oddball.

 

[Josef]

It has to be Berserk for me, it redefined manga for me.

 

[Cyrs]

I support Kingdom. It's my favourite manga right now. It's epic & not too sad/depressing like Berserk.
I won't participate much in this seinen awards because I would just nominate Kingdom in almost all categories.

I'll probably not participate either, because I would support Berserk in all categories. Also, I haven't read Kingdom yet, so I would feel wrong voting against something I haven't read. Maybe if I read a bunch of it before voting is done, I'll vote, haha. Apparently it is worth the read.

 

[0Xellos]

I'll probably not participate either, because I would support Berserk in all categories. Also, I haven't read Kingdom yet, so I would feel wrong voting against something I haven't read. Maybe if I read a bunch of it before voting is done, I'll vote, haha. Apparently it is worth the read.

It's absolutely worth the read. I probably like it because it borders between shounen and seinen.

 

[Wowzers]

I hadn't read any of Kingdom until just last weekend... then I read the whole thing this week (up to current translations + the raws). It is really good, although I found some of the scenes a little repetitive. The latest arc, the Coalition vs Qin is pretty awesome.

 

[tobeulp]

This will be a hard choice for me but voted Monster as it is one of the unique masterpiece I read/watch but close call as there are alot of masterpiece Seinen that I love. I am guessing Kingdom/Berserk will be leading this one ^^

 

[0Xellos]

Yes! Rejoice, my good peoples, for Kingdom has triumphed!

(Fun fact: major asskicking taking place in the poll and in the scanlated manga )

 

[MiyamotoMusashi]

From the choices left, definitely Vinland

 

[zelllogan]

4 very good finalists and my vote go to Kingdom. Monster, Berserk & Vinland Saga are all incredible piece of arts that have good art, good story, good characters ... if I think with my brain, those 3 are probably better than Kingdom, much achieved but if I listen to my heart, it's Kingdom. I really like it beyond reason.

 

[Sky]

~THE WINNER FOR THE BEST OVERALL SEINEN IS~

~BERSERK~

​