Final Voting Round Best Third Party Player

Farfalla · Nov 30, 2020

This thread's purpose is to decide who is the best third party player in Mafia games. Thriving in disadvantageous situations, this player operates in the shadows to deceive the enemies: basically almost every other person in-game.

Note: As these are the first Mafia Game Awards, all Mafia games played so far excluding speed games are eligible for this category.

Voting Round Final

Time: 5 days - Polls open through December 18th
Members can only vote for 1 name out of the remaining nominees.
In case of a tie for most votes, all tied nominees will be considered winners.

Remember that this event is for fun purposes, as always keep the tone friendly and respectful.

To view the rules and general info about the Awards, click [HERE].

Gajeel [11]
Juviii [7]
MarmaladeSky [6]
shinobi [6]
Farfalla [5]
Lady pompom [5]
Lambu [5]

GrySun [4]
Belserion [3]
gnut [3]
Crescent Jinx [1]
Uberfayt [1]
xi0 [1]

@Belserion
@Crescent Jinx
@Farfalla
@Gajeel
@gnut
@GrySun
@Juviii
@Lady pompom
@Lambu
@MarmaladeSky
@shinobi
@uberfayt
@xi0

Hardy · Dec 1, 2020

Has to be Marmalade now?

Evil3ye · Dec 1, 2020

Lambu, Marm and Gajeel

Purity of Magi · Dec 1, 2020

Gajeel and Uber winning the first lovers game and played it very well. Gary for almost winning a game as serial killer in a bomb mechanic game, lol. Meawhile Vindred.... -3-

Copy Panda · Dec 1, 2020

Nacho!

He won twice as lovers, it has to be him

Nominating Gary and Bel as well as they were decent SK as well

Erinyes · Dec 1, 2020

Juviii shapeshifter (twice) Gajeel as lover, (~~Sam as sk edit mistake~~ he was assassin not sk, my bad) shinobi as sk

Elusia · Dec 1, 2020

Gry as Santa Claus (Overlord) :x3

GrySun · Dec 1, 2020

@gnut is usually a good third party player, blue color memes aside I recall him getting far as SK, technically being in hall of fame as first Mentor/Mentee winners, and I think he was TP often enough too to know how to play it.
@Lady pompom feels like she does best as TP, and the Mentor win was nice.
@Farfalla the popular Mentee recruit, think at least 2 times Mentee in my games alone and does very well with it.

Crescent Jinx · Dec 2, 2020

SK still doesn’t have a winner yet? Right? Not seeing anything on hall of fame so going to go with the OG third party role.... serial killer...

1. Belserion as SK - got to last day and it was 2 mafia vs 1 tp vs 2 town.... Ao no exorcist....

2. Gnut as SK made it to the last day. Want to say it was the game right before I started to playing.

3. Gary as SK got to end game in World of Warcraft before my mafia won, ofc.... only fitting way end the game after he killed me and GrySun!!! :sexyarf

4. Cres as SK vs Pandabear and Emperor in ToH on the last day! :pout

Think they were double BP too. That game.... I was going to kill Lambu on N2 but saw it was his birthday so I killed Marma on N2, and then found out it was her birthday.... that her and Lambu have the same birthday!!! Which is why I never forget their birthdays every year!!! And Panda, threatening Empi at endgame :wub

HM goes to Shinobi - the only true Serial killer in the Fam :toc

and the Lambu(?) wasn’t he a serial killer that died to a bomb on N1? Or did I dream that? :grumble

Evil3ye · Dec 2, 2020

There were indeed only very few instances in which we had TP winners. It is significantly hard to overcome the odds and defeat the bigger and stronger factions so each win is a remarkable performance in itself and deserves acknowlwgement. Kudos to everyone succeeding, but also to everyone having tried

##				Player-Faction-outcome
Player	Game #	Theme	Role	victorious	defeated	inconclusive	Total
A.ulq	56	Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat	Mason Lover		1		1
Asako	72	Fullmetal Alchemist	Doctor-Insane Lover		1		1
	82	Yu-Gi-Oh!	Serial Killer		1		1
Battou	64	One-Punch Man	Mentor		1		1
Belserion	65	Ao no Exorcist	Serial Killer		1		1
benelori	42	Mafia Game of Thrones	Mafia Member Lover		1		1
Bugzee	6	game-6	Serial Killer		1		1
Copy Panda	63	Kuroko no Basket	Mafia Assassin Lover		1		1
	74	Akagami no Shirayukihime X Akatsuki no Yona Crossover	Shapeshifter		1		1
Crescent Jinx	62	RWBY Edition	Mafia Mason (II) Lover		1		1
	67	Tower of God: The King's Orders	Serial Killer		1		1
Demonspeed	51	League of Legends: Clown Fiesta	Mafia Mason (I) Lover		1		1
	72	Fullmetal Alchemist	Threesome Candidate Lover		1		1
	73	The Black Card Initiative	Mentee		1		1
	77	Persona 5	Shapeshifter		1		1
desin24	54	JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders	Mafia Strongman Lover		1		1
	62	RWBY Edition	Pirate Lover		1		1
	64	One-Punch Man	Mafia Poisoner (I) Lover		1		1
digitaldude	83	Isekai Quartet	Shapeshifter		1		1
DLord.Van.Buuren	28	Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon Edition	Serial Killer		1		1
Erinyes	73	The Black Card Initiative	Mentor		1		1
Evil3ye	19	The FunForum Edition	Townie Lover		1		1
	85	Shingeki no Kyojin Final arc	Serial Killer Lover		1		1
Farfalla	19	The FunForum Edition	Mafia Member Lover		1		1
	51	League of Legends: Clown Fiesta	Mafia Boss (II) Lover		1		1
	54	JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders	Mentee/Bodyguard		1		1
	59	Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death	Santa Clause		1		1
	81	Puyo Puyo Tetris	Mentee/Townie	1			1
Faust	42	Mafia Game of Thrones	Mafia Member Lover		1		1
Freid	5	game-5	Seriel Killer		1		1
FrostyMouse	22	Death Note Edition	Mentor		1		1
Gajeel	78	The Unholy Grail War	Mafia Mason Lover	1			1
	86	Magic: the Gathering - Planechase	Bulletproof Townie/Threesome Candidate/Lover	1			1
gnut	32	Eyeshield21 Edition	Serial Killer			1	1
	47	Gantz: Survival of the Fittest	Santa Claus		1		1
	59	Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death	Serial Killer		1		1
	73	The Black Card Initiative	Mentor		1		1
	81	Puyo Puyo Tetris	Mentee	1			1
goodboy	54	JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders	Prostitute Lover		1		1
Gryffindor	71	Kingdom Hearts	Serial Killer Lover		1		1
GrySun	61	The Lord od the Rings Edition	Mentor		1		1
	69	Overlord	Santa Claus	1			1
Hardy	26	Tower of God Edition	Mentor		1		1
	75	Nobless x Noragami	Mentee/Detective-Insane	1			1
Holt	63	Kuroko no Basket	Mentor		1		1
	73	The Black Card Initiative	Mentor		1		1
Hystzen	9	Welcome to Brazil retake	Freeman Lover		1		1
James Rye	56	Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat	Santa Claus		1		1
	72	Fullmetal Alchemist	Santa Claus		1		1
Jammin	69	Overlord	Shapeshifter		1		1
	75	Nobless x Noragami	Mentor	1			1
Josef	23	Street Fighter Edition	Mentor		1		1
Juviii	62	RWBY Edition	Shapeshifter		1		1
	78	The Unholy Grail War	Shapeshifter	1			1
Kat	28	Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon Edition	Mafia Member Lover		1		1
-Ken-	46	Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry	Mentor		1		1
kiki	75	Nobless x Noragami	Mentee/Detective-Insane	1			1
Lady pompom	64	One-Punch Man	Mentee		1		1
	81	Puyo Puyo Tetris	Mentor	1			1
Lambu	56	Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat	Serial Killer		1		1
	75	Nobless x Noragami	Mentee/Detective-Sane	1			1
	86	Magic: the Gathering - Planechase	Mafia Noble/Lover	1			1
MarmaladeSky	73	The Black Card Initiative	Serial Killer Hider		1		1
	84	MH Hydra	Santa Claus		1		1
	86	Magic: the Gathering - Planechase	Innocent Child/Lover/Hot Potato	1			1
Mazino	41	End of Fairy Tail	Serial Killer		1		1
	54	JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders	Mentor		1		1
MidoBan	25	One Piece Edition	Serial Killer		1		1
MonkeyD-Dragon	59	Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death	Mafia Janitor Lover		1		1
Naomi	13	game-13	Serial Killer		1		1
Nast.J	28	Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon Edition	Townie Lover		1		1
Nico Brown	40	Konohagakure of Two Minds	Mafia Member (II) Lover		1		1
Nii	23	Street Fighter Edition	Mentee/Vengeful Townie		1		1
	42	Mafia Game of Thrones	Serial Killer		1		1
Nuno	24	League of Legends Edition	Mafia Member Lover		1		1
Philia	49	Pokémon: New Adventure	Mentor		1		1
Raven	85	Shingeki no Kyojin Final arc	Mafia Robber Lover		1		1
scav	40	Konohagakure of Two Minds	Detective-Insane Lover		1		1
Seraph	72	Fullmetal Alchemist	Mafia Detective Lover		1		1
shinobi	71	Kingdom Hearts	Recruiting Mason Traitor (I) Lover		1		1
	75	Nobless x Noragami	Serial Killer		1		1
SirSamuel016	84	MH Hydra	Santa Claus		1		1
SonOfDaws	56	Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat	Mafia Detective (II) Lover		1		1
	59	Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death	Spy Lover		1		1
	64	One-Punch Man	Noble Lover		1		1
	75	Nobless x Noragami	Mentee/Substitute Teacher	1			1
Spirit	58	How to play 13	Mafia Boss (III) Lover		1		1
Takuan	63	Kuroko no Basket	Jesus Lover		1		1
TheBoss	23	Street Fighter Edition	Mentee		1		1
TheMoa	27	Fullmetal Alchemist Edition	Serial Killer		1		1
uberfayt	78	The Unholy Grail War	Sickly Townie Lover	1			1
Vandred	61	The Lord od the Rings Edition	Mentee/Detective-Sane		1		1
	68	World of Warcraft	Serial Killer		1		1
Xadyu	9	Welcome to Brazil retake	Mafia Janitor Lover		1		1
	11	Rome and the Rennaissance	Serial Killer		1		1
	31	Durarara Edition	Serial Killer		1		1
xi0	24	League of Legends Edition	Townie Lover		1		1
	68	World of Warcraft	Serial Killer Hot Potato		1		1
Zasz	55	Overwatch	Santa Claus		1		1
Zeltrax	12	Welcome to the Meiji Era	Serial Killer		1		1
Total				15	84	1	100

Hardy · Dec 2, 2020

TO BE FAIR I was Mentor in game 26...

...

and mafia killed me N1

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 2, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 2, 2020 ---

TheMoa said:
Re: Mafia Game 26 - Tower of God - Day 4

We used the strongman on the first day instead of using the janitor because we thought that the doctor would protect hardy...

FUCKING NIGHT ONE WHAT IS THIS HATE

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 2, 2020 ---

Hardy said:
Re: Mafia Game 26 - Tower of God - Day 4

Let's kill in night 1 the madafaka that wanted to play the most, that died in night 1 in the last game too and that called everyone to play the freaking game

Done with the offtopic '-''''

GrySun · Dec 2, 2020

Evil3ye said:
There were indeed only very few instances in which we had TP winners. It is significantly hard to overcome the odds and defeat the bigger and stronger factions so each win is a remarkable performance in itself and deserves acknowlwgement. Kudos to everyone succeeding, but also to everyone having tried

Player-Faction-outcome
Player Game # Theme Role victorious defeated inconclusive Total
A.ulq
56
Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat Mason Lover
1
1
Asako
72
Fullmetal Alchemist Doctor-Insane Lover
1
1
82
Yu-Gi-Oh! Serial Killer
1
1
Battou
64
One-Punch Man Mentor
1
1
Belserion
65
Ao no Exorcist Serial Killer
1
1
benelori
42
Mafia Game of Thrones Mafia Member Lover
1
1
Bugzee
6
game-6 Serial Killer
1
1
Copy Panda
63
Kuroko no Basket Mafia Assassin Lover
1
1
74
Akagami no Shirayukihime X Akatsuki no Yona Crossover Shapeshifter
1
1
Crescent Jinx
62
RWBY Edition Mafia Mason (II) Lover
1
1
67
Tower of God: The King's Orders Serial Killer
1
1
Demonspeed
51
League of Legends: Clown Fiesta Mafia Mason (I) Lover
1
1
72
Fullmetal Alchemist Threesome Candidate Lover
1
1
73
The Black Card Initiative Mentee
1
1
77
Persona 5 Shapeshifter
1
1
desin24
54
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders Mafia Strongman Lover
1
1
62
RWBY Edition Pirate Lover
1
1
64
One-Punch Man Mafia Poisoner (I) Lover
1
1
digitaldude
83
Isekai Quartet Shapeshifter
1
1
DLord.Van.Buuren
28
Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon Edition Serial Killer
1
1
Erinyes
73
The Black Card Initiative Mentor
1
1
Evil3ye
19
The FunForum Edition Townie Lover
1
1
85
Shingeki no Kyojin Final arc Serial Killer Lover
1
1
Farfalla
19
The FunForum Edition Mafia Member Lover
1
1
51
League of Legends: Clown Fiesta Mafia Boss (II) Lover
1
1
54
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders Mentee/Bodyguard
1
1
59
Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death Santa Clause
1
1
81
Puyo Puyo Tetris Mentee/Townie
1
1
Faust
42
Mafia Game of Thrones Mafia Member Lover
1
1
Freid
5
game-5 Seriel Killer
1
1
FrostyMouse
22
Death Note Edition Mentor
1
1
Gajeel
78
The Unholy Grail War Mafia Mason Lover
1
1
86
Magic: the Gathering - Planechase Bulletproof Townie/Threesome Candidate/Lover
1
1
gnut
32
Eyeshield21 Edition Serial Killer
1
1
47
Gantz: Survival of the Fittest Santa Claus
1
1
59
Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death Serial Killer
1
1
73
The Black Card Initiative Mentor
1
1
81
Puyo Puyo Tetris Mentee
1
1
goodboy
54
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders Prostitute Lover
1
1
Gryffindor
71
Kingdom Hearts Serial Killer Lover
1
1
GrySun
61
The Lord od the Rings Edition Mentor
1
1
69
Overlord Santa Claus
1
1
Hardy
75
Nobless x Noragami Mentee/Detective-Insane
1
1
Holt
63
Kuroko no Basket Mentor
1
1
73
The Black Card Initiative Mentor
1
1
Hystzen
9
Welcome to Brazil retake Freeman Lover
1
1
James Rye
56
Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat Santa Claus
1
1
72
Fullmetal Alchemist Santa Claus
1
1
Jammin
69
Overlord Shapeshifter
1
1
75
Nobless x Noragami Mentor
1
1
Josef
23
Street Fighter Edition Mentor
1
1
Juviii
62
RWBY Edition Shapeshifter
1
1
78
The Unholy Grail War Shapeshifter
1
1
Kat
28
Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon Edition Mafia Member Lover
1
1
-Ken-
46
Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry Mentor
1
1
kiki
75
Nobless x Noragami Mentee/Detective-Insane
1
1
Lady pompom
64
One-Punch Man Mentee
1
1
81
Puyo Puyo Tetris Mentor
1
1
Lambu
56
Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat Serial Killer
1
1
75
Nobless x Noragami Mentee/Detective-Sane
1
1
86
Magic: the Gathering - Planechase Mafia Noble/Lover
1
1
MarmaladeSky
73
The Black Card Initiative Serial Killer Hider
1
1
84
MH Hydra Santa Claus
1
1
86
Magic: the Gathering - Planechase Innocent Child/Lover/Hot Potato
1
1
Mazino
41
End of Fairy Tail Serial Killer
1
1
54
JoJo's Bizarre Adventure: Stardust Crusaders Mentor
1
1
MidoBan
25
One Piece Edition Serial Killer
1
1
MonkeyD-Dragon
59
Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death Mafia Janitor Lover
1
1
Naomi
13
game-13 Serial Killer
1
1
Nast.J
28
Pretty Soldier Sailor Moon Edition Townie Lover
1
1
Nico Brown
40
Konohagakure of Two Minds Mafia Member (II) Lover
1
1
Nii
23
Street Fighter Edition Mentee/Vengeful Townie
1
1
42
Mafia Game of Thrones Serial Killer
1
1
Nuno
24
League of Legends Edition Mafia Member Lover
1
1
Philia
49
Pokémon: New Adventure Mentor
1
1
Raven
85
Shingeki no Kyojin Final arc Mafia Robber Lover
1
1
scav
40
Konohagakure of Two Minds Detective-Insane Lover
1
1
Seraph
72
Fullmetal Alchemist Mafia Detective Lover
1
1
shinobi
71
Kingdom Hearts Recruiting Mason Traitor (I) Lover
1
1
75
Nobless x Noragami Serial Killer
1
1
SirSamuel016
84
MH Hydra Santa Claus
1
1
SonOfDaws
56
Dragon Ball Z: A New Threat Mafia Detective (II) Lover
1
1
59
Shingeki no Kyojin: Festival of Death Spy Lover
1
1
64
One-Punch Man Noble Lover
1
1
75
Nobless x Noragami Mentee/Substitute Teacher
1
1
Spirit
58
How to play 13 Mafia Boss (III) Lover
1
1
Takuan
63
Kuroko no Basket Jesus Lover
1
1
TheBoss
23
Street Fighter Edition Mentee
1
1
TheMoa
27
Fullmetal Alchemist Edition Serial Killer
1
1
uberfayt
78
The Unholy Grail War Sickly Townie Lover
1
1
Vandred
61
The Lord od the Rings Edition Mentee/Detective-Sane
1
1
68
World of Warcraft Serial Killer
1
1
Xadyu
9
Welcome to Brazil retake Mafia Janitor Lover
1
1
11
Rome and the Rennaissance Serial Killer
1
1
31
Durarara Edition Serial Killer
1
1
xi0
24
League of Legends Edition Townie Lover
1
1
68
World of Warcraft Serial Killer Hot Potato
1
1
Zasz
55
Overwatch Santa Claus
1
1
Zeltrax
12
Welcome to the Meiji Era Serial Killer
1
1
Total
18
80
1
99

Something feels wrong about some of these. Don‘t think Jammin won in Game 69 as Shapeshifter, or Daws as town Noble Lover in 64

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 2, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 2, 2020 ---

Weirdness of Game 75 aside, shinobi wasn‘t in the winning group of 4 either. One third party winning doesn‘t win it for the other third parties in the game, does it? :hmm

Evil3ye · Dec 2, 2020

Was a quick assessment I did, some mistakes here and there cannot be ruled out of course. But if you have a better data set, please share. :vbunny

I mean, if somebody would have told me we have an award show this week, I could have cleaned up a little in prep :rolleyes:

GrySun · Dec 2, 2020

Evil3ye said:
Was a quick assessment I did, some mistakes here and there cannot be ruled out of course. But if you have a better data set, please share.

I mean, if somebody would have told me we have an award show this week, I could have cleaned up a little in prep

Just doing helpful feedback, overall it‘s very good.

Somebody surely wanted it to be a big surprise.