Final Voting Round Best Third Party Player

[Vandred]

This thread's purpose is to decide who is the best third party player in Mafia games. Thriving in disadvantageous situations, this player operates in the shadows to deceive the enemies: basically almost every other person in-game.

Voting Round Final

• Time: 5 days -> until December 8th
• Members can only vote for one name out of the remaining nominees.
• In case of a tie for most votes, all tied nominees will be considered winners.
• Remember that we are focusing on players and games from the past year (from Game 87 - Baccano! and onward).

Spoiler: Voting Round 1

1. Juviii. [12]
2. Gajeel. [11]
3. GrySun. [6]
   
   
4. SonOfDaws. [4]
5. Evil3ye. [3]

Spoiler: Nominees

1. Evil3ye.
2. Gajeel.
3. GrySun.
4. Juviii.
5. SonOfDaws.

Remember that this event is for fun purposes. As always, keep the tone friendly and respectful.

To view the rules and general info about the Awards, click [HERE].

 

[GrySun]

We had no third party wins this year, unlike last year where we had a couple. Also this year we had less TPs in games than last years too.

I'll nominate Gajeel and Daws for being good at dancing on the fine line between too present and not present enough when TP, with Gajeel maybe doing it a bit better.
Also gonna add me and Juviii as Lovers for almost winning if not for random-kun, after like 5-6 days of suffering. But I'm unsure if it's really a legit nomination since it was some game mechanic fuckery that only made us TP after a couple of phases instead of from the beggining, so leaving that to the event mods.

 

[Purity of Magi]

@Gajeel

 

[Lambu]

Nominating @Evil3ye for his Lover play in the last game.

 

[Evil3ye]

Couple of basic stats* here before evaluations. Unfortunately we had no Third Party win this nomination year, but couple TPs come pretty close(-ish?)..
*All numbers including substitudes.

We have 3 players have been Third Parties 2x in the last eleven (18%). Most notably here Belserion, who played 4 games in total in this period and was TP half the time, at a 50% TP rate. In the two games I have been TP, one was without mafia complete, so "third" party classification might be debatable here.

Player	Mafia	Town	Third Party	Total	Mafia percentage	Townie percentage	Third Party percentage
Belserion		2​	2​	4​	0%​	50%​	50%​
Evil3ye	1​	4​	2​	7​	14%​	57%​	29%​
Holt	1​	6​	2​	9​	11%​	67%​	22%​

Spoiler: 2x TP Players yearly Performance

Player	Game #	Theme	Primary Role	Secondary Role	Time of outcome	Player-outcome	Player-Faction-outcome
Belserion	87​	Baccano!	Noble/Threesome Candidate	Lover	06 Night	suicided	defeated
	96​	Civilization	Mentee/Townie	Jesus	05 Day	suicided	defeated
Evil3ye	88​	Pokemon Mystery Dungeon	Mentee/Spirit Medium		03 Day	lynched	defeated
	97​	Omoneko: Answer Arc	Mortician	Lover (II)	08 Day	suicided	defeated
Holt	87​	Baccano!	Santa Claus	Lover	02 Day	lynched	defeated
	89​	Mafia Jump - OMO weekly	Shapeshifter		03 Day	lynched	defeated

16 further players have been TP 1x in the last eleven (9%).

Player	Mafia	Town	Third Party	Total	Mafia percentage	Townie percentage	Third Party percentage
xnut			1​	1​	0%​	0%​	100%​
Mazino		1​	1​	2​	0%​	50%​	50%​
Juviii	1​	1​	1​	3​	33%​	33%​	33%​
shinobi		3​	1​	4​	0%​	75%​	25%​
Seraph	1​	2​	1​	4​	25%​	50%​	25%​
Hardy	2​	1​	1​	4​	50%​	25%​	25%​
Lambu		4​	1​	5​	0%​	80%​	20%​
Brandish µ	2​	2​	1​	5​	40%​	40%​	20%​
SonOfDaws	1​	4​	1​	6​	17%​	67%​	17%​
Gajeel	2​	4​	1​	7​	29%​	57%​	14%​
Sakura Taichou	2​	4​	1​	7​	29%​	57%​	14%​
SirSamuel016	2​	5​	1​	8​	25%​	63%​	13%​
James Rye	3​	4​	1​	8​	38%​	50%​	13%​
GrySun	2​	6​	1​	9​	22%​	67%​	11%​
Demonspeed	3​	5​	1​	9​	33%​	56%​	11%​
digitaldude	3​	7​	1​	11​	27%​	64%​	9%​

Spoiler: 1x TP Players yearly Performance

Player	Game #	Theme	Primary Role	Secondary Role	Time of outcome	Player-outcome	Player-Faction-outcome
Brandish µ	89​	Mafia Jump - OMO weekly	Santa Claus		02 Day	lynched	defeated
Demonspeed	88​	Pokemon Mystery Dungeon	Mentee/Spirit Medium		03 Day	lynched	defeated
digitaldude	88​	Pokemon Mystery Dungeon	Mentor		04 Day	lynched	defeated
Gajeel	97​	Omoneko: Answer Arc	Serial Killer	Paranoid-Gun Owner	09 Day	lynched	defeated
GrySun	95​	Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac	Psychiatrist	Lover	09 Night	suicided	defeated
Hardy	97​	Omoneko: Answer Arc	Mafia Boss	Mafia Mason/Lover (I)	03 Day	killed	defeated
James Rye	88​	Pokemon Mystery Dungeon	Mentor		04 Day	lynched	defeated
Juviii	95​	Saint Seiya: Era of the Zodiac	Mafia Boss	Lover	09 Day	lynched	defeated
Lambu	88​	Pokemon Mystery Dungeon	Mentee/Necromancer		04 Day	suicided	defeated
Mazino	89​	Mafia Jump - OMO weekly	Mentor		04 Day	lynched	defeated
Sakura Taichou	97​	Omoneko: Answer Arc	Mafia Poisoner	Illusion/Lover (II)	07 Night/06 Night	kiled	defeated
Seraph	87​	Baccano!	Mentor		01 Day	lynched	defeated
shinobi	97​	Omoneko: Answer Arc	Spirit Medium	Lover (I)	03 Night	suicided	defeated
SirSamuel016	88​	Pokemon Mystery Dungeon	Mentee/Necromancer		04 Day	suicided	defeated
SonOfDaws	96​	Civilization	Mentor		05 Day	lynched	defeated
xnut	87​	Baccano!	Prostitute	Lover	05 Night	killed	defeated

 

[digitaldude]

Third parties let us down this year, but I'll say SonofDaws and Gajeel.

 

[Brandish μ]

me and Juviii as Lovers

I support this.

Was curious how coldblooded Juviii was in the Mafia Pad with James, given love was out in the open lol.

 

[Copy Panda]

@GrySun and @Juviii for their lover play; they got RNG'd into the role late but made the best of it. Also, @Gajeel for surviving as long as he did as SK during the omoneko game