Final Voting Round Best Town Player

Farfalla · Nov 30, 2020

This thread's purpose is to decide who is the best town player in Mafia games. It's remarkable how this person excels when he/she plays as a part of the good side, uncovering the villains and being a differential among the townspeople.

Note: As these are the first Mafia Game Awards, all Mafia games played so far excluding speed games are eligible for this category.

Voting Round Final

Time: 5 days - Polls open through December 18th
Members can only vote for 1 name out of the remaining nominees.
In case of a tie for most votes, all tied nominees will be considered winners.

Remember that this event is for fun purposes, as always keep the tone friendly and respectful.

To view the rules and general info about the Awards, click [HERE].

GrySun [17]
Hardy [7]
Farfalla [6]
Holt [6]
Copy Panda [5]
Crescent Jinx [5]
Erinyes [5]

Belserion [4]
Gryffindor [4]
Evil3ye [3]
Vandred [3]
Nii [1]
Ustegius [1]

@Belserion
@Copy Panda
@Crescent Jinx
@Erinyes
@Evil3ye
@Farfalla
@Gryffindor
@GrySun
@Hardy
@Holt
@Nii
@Ustegius
@Vandred

Hardy · Dec 1, 2020

Vindred

Evil3ye · Dec 1, 2020

Empirical data shows best townie player to be Crescent Jinx. Faction win rate of 89%.

Player	victorious	defeated	Total	win-to-lose
Crescent Jinx	8	1	9	89%
benelori	5	1	6	83%
Faust	8	2	10	80%
MidoBan	8	2	10	80%
Gryffindor	7	2	9	78%
Nuno	7	2	9	78%
Nii	6	2	8	75%
EmptySoul	5	2	7	71%
shinobi	5	2	7	71%
xi0	12	5	17	71%
Vandred	9	4	13	69%
DLord.Van.Buuren	4	2	6	67%
Hardy	13	7	20	65%
Kat	7	4	11	64%
Philia	5	3	8	63%
Lady pompom	8	5	13	62%
Lambu	8	5	13	62%
Organizized	8	5	13	62%
Xadyu	11	7	18	61%
desin24	12	8	20	60%
Evil3ye	6	4	10	60%
Asako	7	5	12	58%
BBB Banana	7	5	12	58%
gnut	20	16	36	56%
Hakuteiken	6	5	11	55%
scav	6	5	11	55%
SonOfDaws	8	7	15	53%
Erinyes	9	8	17	53%
Farfalla	23	21	44	52%
Zasz	14	13	27	52%
digitaldude	18	18	36	50%
James Rye	12	12	24	50%
Imperium	10	10	20	50%
Mazino	10	10	20	50%
Seraph	7	7	14	50%
Kato756	5	5	10	50%
kdowns	4	4	8	50%
After_Image	3	3	6	50%
Brandish µ	3	3	6	50%
Belserion	6	7	13	46%
Takuan	5	6	11	45%
Demonspeed	11	14	25	44%
Holt	11	14	25	44%
goodboy	14	18	32	44%
Ustegius	7	9	16	44%
Adorien	3	4	7	43%
Naomi	3	4	7	43%
xnut	3	4	7	43%
Zeltrax	3	4	7	43%
Copy Panda	7	10	17	41%
Spirit	4	6	10	40%
GrySun	8	14	22	36%
MarmaladeSky	5	9	14	36%
Channy	2	4	6	33%
Gajeel	2	4	6	33%
Juviii	2	6	8	25%
Bugzee	1	5	6	17%
Purity of Magi	1	5	6	17%

Player	victorious	defeated	Total	win-to-lose
thornofcarrion	5		5	100%
CBlitz	4		4	100%
M3J	3		3	100%
Aizen	2		2	100%
Macaco	2		2	100%
Nast.J	2		2	100%
ProGoddess	2		2	100%
Reebi	2		2	100%
shinsengumi	2		2	100%
TheBoss	2		2	100%
Xerous	2		2	100%
A.ulq	1		1	100%
Akiyama	1		1	100%
Anih	1		1	100%
BakaHaze	1		1	100%
Beatrice	1		1	100%
BluePegasus	1		1	100%
Cat Sidhe26	1		1	100%
Commanderaxe	1		1	100%
Darjaille	1		1	100%
Gats	1		1	100%
googlez_kun	1		1	100%
Kazu-Sama	1		1	100%
-Ken-	1		1	100%
kiki	1		1	100%
kindredxiuxiu	1		1	100%
Nietz	1		1	100%
Notice me Escanor senpai	1		1	100%
Shobu_Yoruichi	1		1	100%
Sidmo	1		1	100%
Sky	1		1	100%
uberfayt	1		1	100%
Crescent Jinx	8	1	9	89%
benelori	5	1	6	83%
Faust	8	2	10	80%
MidoBan	8	2	10	80%
Buffynut	4	1	5	80%
Gryffindor	7	2	9	78%
Nuno	7	2	9	78%
Nii	6	2	8	75%
Arctigor	3	1	4	75%
Josef	3	1	4	75%
kkck	3	1	4	75%
wizzard	3	1	4	75%
EmptySoul	5	2	7	71%
shinobi	5	2	7	71%
xi0	12	5	17	71%
Vandred	9	4	13	69%
DLord.Van.Buuren	4	2	6	67%
Leoat12	2	1	3	67%
Tatasugoi	2	1	3	67%
Hardy	13	7	20	65%
Kat	7	4	11	64%
Philia	5	3	8	63%
Lady pompom	8	5	13	62%
Lambu	8	5	13	62%
Organizized	8	5	13	62%
Xadyu	11	7	18	61%
desin24	12	8	20	60%
Evil3ye	6	4	10	60%
FrostyMouse	3	2	5	60%
jorped	3	2	5	60%
Asako	7	5	12	58%
BBB Banana	7	5	12	58%
gnut	20	16	36	56%
Hakuteiken	6	5	11	55%
scav	6	5	11	55%
SonOfDaws	8	7	15	53%
Erinyes	9	8	17	53%
Farfalla	23	21	44	52%
Zasz	14	13	27	52%
digitaldude	18	18	36	50%
James Rye	12	12	24	50%
Imperium	10	10	20	50%
Mazino	10	10	20	50%
Seraph	7	7	14	50%
Kato756	5	5	10	50%
kdowns	4	4	8	50%
After_Image	3	3	6	50%
Brandish µ	3	3	6	50%
Arjuna	2	2	4	50%
Hermit	2	2	4	50%
Pirulito	2	2	4	50%
syx	2	2	4	50%
TheMoa	2	2	4	50%
destiny4ever	1	1	2	50%
kakashi919	1	1	2	50%
kira	1	1	2	50%
Spectrum	1	1	2	50%
Belserion	6	7	13	46%
Takuan	5	6	11	45%
Demonspeed	11	14	25	44%
Holt	11	14	25	44%
goodboy	14	18	32	44%
Ustegius	7	9	16	44%
Adorien	3	4	7	43%
Naomi	3	4	7	43%
xnut	3	4	7	43%
Zeltrax	3	4	7	43%
Copy Panda	7	10	17	41%
Spirit	4	6	10	40%
BlackTiger	2	3	5	40%
GrySun	8	14	22	36%
MarmaladeSky	5	9	14	36%
Channy	2	4	6	33%
Gajeel	2	4	6	33%
Freid	1	2	3	33%
Geshode	1	2	3	33%
Hystzen	1	2	3	33%
Jammin	1	2	3	33%
matzik1212	1	2	3	33%
revo	1	2	3	33%
Shinsatsu	1	2	3	33%
Totinona	1	2	3	33%
Juviii	2	6	8	25%
Aonori	1	3	4	25%
blai	1	3	4	25%
Charlie	1	3	4	25%
sakura-aneki	1	4	5	20%
Bugzee	1	5	6	17%
Purity of Magi	1	5	6	17%
Raven		3	3	0%
BD_Beno		2	2	0%
Esu Taicho		2	2	0%
g01		2	2	0%
Knightmare of heavan 0	2	2	0%
Qixus		2	2	0%
SirSamuel016		2	2	0%
Alphabeta		1	1	0%
Battou		1	1	0%
Devil Hunter		1	1	0%
Elusia		1	1	0%
George		1	1	0%
goldb		1	1	0%
Hll		1	1	0%
Moegara		1	1	0%
MonkeyD-Dragon		1	1	0%
Ramen		1	1	0%
Rikudou King		1	1	0%
Shad		1	1	0%
SheepyTurtle		1	1	0%
SonOfDows		1	1	0%
steelwingcrash1		1	1	0%
SugarKitty		1	1	0%
Teubier		1	1	0%
Utsune		1	1	0%
xAznSinnage		1	1	0%
Zirconium		1	1	0%

Hardy · Dec 1, 2020

Yeah but Van's winrate is 69%, checkmate.

SonOfDaws · Dec 1, 2020

GrySun

Hardy · Dec 1, 2020

SonOfDaws said:
GrySun

Biggest loser according to the stats, you guys are letting him down!!!

Evil3ye · Dec 1, 2020

Hardy said:
Biggest loser according to the stats, you guys are letting him down!!!

His biggest mistake was missing out on the digital era

Those stats of course are to take with lot of grains of salt, as they don't really take any time values/progressions into account, it's just the naked numbers. But as Mafia Game player gotta love some stats, no

SonOfDaws · Dec 1, 2020

Hardy said:
Biggest loser according to the stats, you guys are letting him down!!!

He draws too much attention to quickly, but even if he hasn't figured out when to lose or draw suspicion when needed, I think he's worth a nomination nonetheless.

Farfalla · Dec 1, 2020

I think Hardy made a joke with Gry indeed standing out but town usually being too heavy lmao

scav · Dec 2, 2020

I support @Crescent Jinx nomination

8 wins out of 9 games. that's fucking impressive.
I guess that's what you expect from people working at umbrella corp :fan

Brandish μ · Dec 2, 2020

GrySun
Holt
Erinyes

They are helpful to town, which isn't easy.

Elusia · Dec 2, 2020

Gry, Holt and Cres o/

Demonspeed · Dec 2, 2020

For now:

Bel:I don't remember her playing bad as a Town even once regardless of her role.
Gryffindor.

I really need to revisit threads.

GrySun · Dec 2, 2020

To me a good town player is someone who is both hard to lynch(so mafia has to resort to nightkill or outnumber) and someone who is good at finding mafia among the town:

@Copy Panda is an insanely good town player, I am still trying to understand whatever it is he does to get ignored by mafia in most games and to never be nightkilled, then proceeding to win most of the games in lategame.
@Farfalla mainly for how genuine she sounds when town making it impossible to properly frame and lynch her, hell even as mafia that can be difficult sometimes.
@Hardy very disagreeable in some games but I do recall some pretty decent town moments and overall good nose for scum detection.
@Evil3ye can be pretty good as town and annoyingly aggressive, though granted he hasn‘t been town a lot in the last years, only recall him being town in YuGiOh and WoW, in both he assumed the town lead spot pretty fast and lived long, and in both he just so happens to be town when I‘m mafia Good thing there‘s Belserion to tank his gaze for a while.

Crescent Jinx · Dec 3, 2020

For the record, the only game I lost as town was because my fellow townie Mr. Van D. Red decided he wanted to lynch the town noble (me) on D1 while I was busy at work.

Jinx Wesker, doesn’t get mad. She gets even.

Sincerely, The Umbrella Corporation

Copy Panda · Dec 3, 2020

GrySun said:
To me a good town player is someone who is both hard to lynch(so mafia has to resort to nightkill or outnumber) and someone who is good at finding mafia among the town:

@Copy Panda is an insanely good town player, I am still trying to understand whatever it is he does to get ignored by mafia in most games and to never be nightkilled, then proceeding to win most of the games in lategame

Aigoo how could someone kill a panda :hmph

GrySun · Dec 3, 2020

Copy Panda said:
Aigoo how could someone kill a panda

Like look at some of your games, I can think of 3 from the top of my head where it‘s final phase with you still alive :XD

I guess I must do an animal transformation myself...

Copy Panda · Dec 3, 2020

Sleep early game, scale late game

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 3, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 3, 2020 ---

Thinking about it, there's a bunch of games I was killed just before the final phase as well. I wonder if mafia thinks I'm too cute to be threatening or sth

Demonspeed · Dec 3, 2020

Copy Panda said:
Sleep early game, scale late game

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 3, 2020, Original Post Date: Dec 3, 2020 ---

Thinking about it, there's a bunch of games I was killed just before the final phase as well. I wonder if mafia thinks I'm too cute to be threatening or sth

So you miss the "Panda doesn't live beyond D3" era huh? Noted. :fan

Evil3ye · Dec 3, 2020

GrySun said:
@Evil3ye can be pretty good as town and annoyingly aggressive, though granted he hasn‘t been town a lot in the last years, only recall him being town in YuGiOh and WoW, in both he assumed the town lead spot pretty fast and lived long, and in both he just so happens to be town when I‘m mafia Good thing there‘s Belserion to tank his gaze for a while.

So is that a compliment to me or yourself now haha

Either way, in both those game it was a pleasure lynching you. :toc

Final Voting Round Best Town Player

Best Town Player

Copy Panda

Crescent Jinx

Erinyes

Farfalla

GrySun

Hardy

Holt

The Witch of Drama

Mangahelper

Registered User

Mangahelper

Registered User

Mangahelper

Registered User

Registered User

The Witch of Drama

MH's Most Passionate Member

Can you?

Registered User

The Hero of the Trojan War

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

The Hero of the Trojan War

Registered User