Misc Attempt Cleaning attempts ~

[Shid0x]

Hello people of MangaHelpers~
I would like you to rate some of my cleans and give me advices if possible , since i've started a small Edited Manga team i would like to know what people other than my followers think about it.

I've used Photoshop cs5 + Topaz


RAW :

Spoiler

Cleaned :

Spoiler

well here's another one :

Spoiler

Cleaned :

Spoiler

Thanks !

 

[Name-Undecided]

The grays! What have you done to the grays?!

I'd like to say something positive, but I'm very much against the use of Topaz and other "brute force" filters. I think they produce a messy, blurry, unnatural, unmangalike result, especially with the way they completely ruin screentone textures.

So why did I post? Because you'd be lonely if no one posted, right?

 

[Shid0x]

Thanks for the answer .
As for the gray i think Topaz kinda ''burn'' them.

 

[Name-Undecided]

Try cleaning it without using Topaz and see what you get. Just for fun.