Joint Review of Berserk 325

[benelori]

So this is the thread for Berserk 325, and I made it, because we agreed on a seinen title, and it got the most votes.
So there you go. You can sign up here.

 

[alphabeta]

I'm not up to date with Berserk, but I suppose I could help out with the Bonus section

 

[Josef]

I sure am in for this one. I would like to do a character spotlights and analysis the most.

 

[alphabeta]

I sure am in for this one. I would like to do a character spotlights and analysis the most.

analysis.... we have an analysis section?


we have to make a standartified review format template

 

[Josef]

It's fine, we can have these type of add ons just like you had the fanfic stuff in the Fairy Tail review.

 

[alphabeta]

It's fine, we can have these type of add ons just like you had the fanfic stuff in the Fairy Tail review.

we have a bonus section in all reviews, Jo

In the end Long Summary is the same as Analysis no matter how you look at it.

 

[Josef]

Ah perhaps I should be clearer, this is an analysis that involves a certain character, in detail, and Berserk being Berserk it offers plenty of good stuff for such a thing. Long summary is both characters and story but I think there we will concentrate more on the story.

 

[alphabeta]

Ah perhaps I should be clearer, this is an analysis that involves a certain character, in detail, and Berserk being Berserk it offers plenty of good stuff for such a thing. Long summary is both characters and story but I think there we will concentrate more on the story.

So basically you want to do a bigger version of the Character Spotlight?

 

[Josef]

No, that is separate, separate from that section at least, character spotlight is a reaction to which character had the spotlight in this chapter, while the analysis is a certain character and his analysis within the arc with accent on the chapter, for this one I like to choose Isma. Not telling anything for those that have not read it yet or are not caught up.

 

[alphabeta]

I see. I just want to avoid the case where 2 people write the same thing >_>

 

[Josef]

I will write spotlight as well as I said. Either way in this chapter the spotlight is not the same character, at least for me.

 

[benelori]

analysis.... we have an analysis section?


we have to make a standartified review format template

He meant character analysis...

Anyways...let's wait for others as well...I would definitely take small summary...

---------- Post added November 21, 2011 at 11:23 AM ---------- Previous post was November 13, 2011 at 01:28 AM ----------

We can definitely try to tackle this just the two of us Josef.
Suggest a format please, or are we going with what we have?

 

[Josef]

Something like this maybe:

Intro/Short Summary:

Long Summary of the chapter (with connection to the arc and overall story itself):

Artistic Appeal, art critique:

Character Spotlight:

Character Analysis:

Fun section/bonus:

Predictions/Theories:

 

[benelori]

Something like this maybe:

Intro/Short Summary:

Long Summary of the chapter (with connection to the arc and overall story itself):

Artistic Appeal, art critique:

Character Spotlight:

Character Analysis:

Fun section/bonus:

Predictions/Theories:

I'm not fan of the bonus section, but if you want to do it, then it's okay with me....what do you choose for URself, what do you want to do? And are we setting a deadline for this?

 

[Josef]

Me too, but I put it there so that we can put some stuff that we could not find a proper place for in the review but we might come up with later on. It may not have anything in the end but it's there just to be sure. I will take Intro/Short Summary, Character Analysis, Artistic Appeal and one half of long summary, since we are doing it both might as well split it equally.

 

[benelori]

Well it would be cool, if you would post/send via PM, the long summary at least, so that I can organize my ideas around yours...coherence issues and all that

 

[alphabeta]

Right, I know we still don't have an archive, but shouldn't this thread at least be removed from the stickies? There's already a bunch of threads over there, I don't see a point in having a dead thread as a sticky as well.