Voting Round 4 Koe no Katachi vs. Fullmetal Alchemist

[Sky]

	​
Koe no Katachi Yoshitoki Oima ​	-	Fullmetal Alchemist Hiromu Arakawa​

Rules
- You are allowed to vote for one Manga
- After 5 days, the Manga with the most votes will proceed into the next round
- In case of a tie, a staff pick will break it

 

[Static]

Gonna wait out for the campaigns for this one before voting.

 

[kkck]

Going for FMA, on account on having read that one.

 

[Lambu]

So its my turn to get stomped huh?

Credits to @kira , he saw it coming since the WW.

This doesn't mean I'll give up, oh no, I will fight till the end.

 

[Demonspeed]

Instavote for KnK. FMA crushed its opponents because of its popularity more than anything. Magi can't win like this!

 

[kira]

you have my vote @Lambu ! Magi-senpai keeps voting against HxH anyway.

the first one I can forgive since it was against Magi. The second one..uhm.. I can also forgive since it was for Haya-san. but still !!!

 

[Spirit]

Voted for FMA. Sometimes in my eyes, a series gains popularity for a good reason. At this point I want to see FMA win this. If Magi won't campaign then maybe I should.

 

[Demonspeed]

you have my vote @Lambu ! Magi-senpai keeps voting against HxH anyway.

the first one I can forgive since it was against Magi. The second one..uhm.. I can also forgive since it was for Haya-san. but still !!!

You know very well why you should not vote for FMA, kira-san .

 

[kira]

You know very well why you should not vote for FMA, kira-san .

oh shizzle! I didn't even notice. and that makes two of us.


let's give our all against each other(or just vote HxH! your fave!!) and give our all to crush FMA as well then!
but if that does happen, then one of us will be up against Lambu

 

[Farfalla]

I don't fully agree with Demon, but I do agree that popularity made it a lot easier for FMA. I'm still gonna cringe like hell if FMA make it to the final to lose to Naruto...

 

[TotalEconomist]

Koe what now? Is it something better than eye bleach?

My vote is for FMA, to which I've read bits and pieces of and has great characters like Lust and Armstrong

 

[Demonspeed]

but if that does happen, then one of us will be up against Lambu

Heh, who cares? If NNT loses I will be freed and fully support HxH, my favorite manga. If NNT wins I will be able to campaign again.

I win in both scenarios.

 

[Vici]

I may read the campaign posts from Lambu in previous rounds before voting on this one

Ofc FmA will have that advantage that I have completed that series but KnK making this far it may be solid series and good recommendation for future..

 

[Lambu]

Well people, this is it.

An amazing manga, not that popular yet but loved to no extent by everyone who read it, a work of fiction that I can see becoming one of the leading titles of Japanese drama history.
This manga... is against the legend Fullmetal Alchemist is, a work that is worth all its fame and has the title of best shonen manga ever created by millions of readers.

What can I do or say to convince all these fans that love FMA and consider it the best (for example @WithYouInSpirit , I can tell he's a great fan of it), whats more, I could include myself in that group. FMA is amazing and deserves every bit of appreciation it received all these years.

So why vote Koe no Katachi? why vote the series that's so so good but still so so little in comparison to this giant of manganime?

Because it has the potential to become great aswell

Guys I think the point of this event (just like in the Waifu Wars was with the 2D girls) is not to get the most famous manga or the most perfect one to get to the finals. Sure the option has to be good, not enough people would vote something solely for the campaigning effort or "alliances" and such, but the potential and the dedication given to it for that is what really makes it stand.
Naruto's example is a very good one in the other threads, it might not be superior in many terms to its rivals (I'll be honest here, Berserk losing was sad...) but the effort put by @Emperor Spriggan and him taking out all the good points of the manga he promotes made Naruto a worthy entry and rival for the crown for "Best Manga".

In other words, its the dedication of the fans to make their manga stand out over others what matters in this event, just like the "waifu that gets more love" deserves to be the best one.
Koe no Katachi might not be as big as giants like HxH, FMA, Death Note and many others, but it can definitely stand against those if its presented correctly and manage to get your attention people, thats why Im here to show you this manga so you know it from now on and then, maybe, give it a chance to compete.

This is why I ask of you to at least, please dont instavote FMA because you assume its the better candidate when the other one is as worthy of passing this round.
If you think FMA is better then fine, but if you have the littlest doubt about it then please hold the vote a little longer, I'll present and analyze KnK for you.

So I'll be campaigning this as much as I can with my time, I hope you enjoy it.

 

[Kiki]

Koe no Katachi

 

[Lady pompom]

I'll be giving a chance to koe no katachi. Lambu's campaign was good and I've heard many good comments about the manga outside the forums either. FMA is exceptional too, but I should give a chance to other mangas.

 

[Shobu_Yoruichi]

I was preparing a catch phrase to use for the Bleach Vs FMA

"It's Quimerastastic"

So... Koe i haven't read it, but i suppose Envy does pretty much what it would appear there, so my vote goes to FMA

 

[Hermit]

Naruto's example is a very good one in the other threads, it might not be superior in many terms to its rivals (I'll be honest here, Berserk losing was sad...) but the effort put by @Emperor Spriggan and him taking out all the good points of the manga he promotes made Naruto a worthy entry and rival for the crown for "Best Manga".

Gracias.
I voted Koe because of this post, now I wanna see you go places man, solid stuff

 

[GrySun]

Omg Koe no Katachi is doing it

This may be it‘s end though, I find it hard voting between these two since I love both. But will support the underdog.

 

[TotalEconomist]

Honestly, FMA is a great series even if you only read bits of pieces of it. It's really hard for me to go against at this point until it meets something I can really back.