Fantasy Luffy vs Shanks

[LadyVados]

How does Luffy fare against Shanks ?

 

[really_jonny]

I think Shanks is stronger than Luffy with all Haki advanced in all stats, though not so much that Luffy doesn't give him a good fight.

At some point Luffy would use G5 and case decide to attack Shanks with all brutality, he wins with a single use.

 

[afromarco005]

Luffy’s fresh gear five is above shanks. Luffy wins high diff (giving shanks the benefit of the doubt because of his title ).

However if all Shanks has is haki then Luffy mid-high diffs.

 

[Nie Li]

Luffy’s fresh gear five is above shanks. Luffy wins high diff (giving shanks the benefit of the doubt because of his title ).

However if all Shanks has is haki then Luffy mid-high diffs.

Why does it make a difference if all he has is haki? With just haki and swordsmanship he's supposed to be around Kaido's level.

Unless, of course, we rank Shanks as more similar to Big Mom's level than Kaido's, but it still wouldn't matter if he has more than haki or not.

 

[Ricko]

I think Shank will take it because he's a bad matchup.
Kaido may be stronger than him, I see Shank as deadlier.

Kaido love take hits, break the mind of his opponent and have a good fight.
Shank don't seem to bother of those, a supernova come to argue with him... He cut his arm... No waste of time.

Against Luffy he may not be as cold, but in a real battle condition he will go for the win as quick as possible... While Luffy is like Kaido, more playing around and no go serious at the begining of a fight.