Voting Rules:
- This Battle is a 1 vs 1.
- You may vote for one character in this fight.
- So you voted early and someone/something changed your mind? You can use the 'Change Vote' option to choose again.
Selene jobbed, but all that damage was real. He has the attack power to deal good damage to human DG tiers if they decide to job. Which is something that can't be said for anyone else except DF NatsuHad this been before the latest chapter, I would have said Suzaku high diffs DF Natsu, but, I've changed my mind.
Suzaku wipes the floor with base Natsu, but, if Natsu goes Dragon Force, it's all over. It was revealed that Selene jobbed and that Suzaku didn't really hurt her at all, he only really cut into her gut in an attack in which she deliberately took, while Dragon Force Natsu defeated a nerfed Dragon God.
So, Suzaku stomps base Natsu, DF Natsu stomps Suzaku.
I'm not saying that the damage that Selene took wasn't real, he managed to slice into her flesh, and that is impressive as not many could have damaged her even if she allowed them free hits, and I stand by the argument I made in an earlier thread, that I don't think Erza could have done the same had Acnologia tried to deliberately allow her to do damage to him.Selene jobbed, but all that damage was real. He has the attack power to deal good damage to human DG tiers if they decide to job. Which is something that can't be said for anyone else except DF Natsu
On bold part, no.I'm not saying that the damage that Selene took wasn't real, he managed to slice into her flesh, and that is impressive as not many could have damaged her even if she allowed them free hits, and I stand by the argument I made in an earlier thread, that I don't think Erza could have done the same had Acnologia tried to deliberately allow her to do damage to him.
But, the thing is, I think that Selene could have easily gotten up and just shrugged off his attack like it was nothing. Sure, he damaged her, he gave her a flesh wound, I just don't think he did much or meaningful damage to her.
I agree that the attack basically should be treated like it would be an off guard attack.Damaging your enemy when they aren't in fighting stance isn't a feat. This has been demonstrated in the series multiple times before. Brandish stabbed August when he had his guard down. Dimaria sliced Brandish with a mere knife when Brandish can tank attacks from Taurus Lucy. Taurus Lucy has kicked harder than Gajeel on an instance. Brandish could use her magic on Natsu when he wasn't in battle stance. As far as I am concerned that damage to Selene which she deliberately took means absolutely nothing. She let her guard down intentionally , and she very likely lowered her magical defenses to the level how they are when one is not aware of a fight. Suzaku deserved to win in the previous round cause his feat of oneshotting Natsu and Erza hasn't been replicated by Gildarts yet , but here he literally has no chance.
This :
VS
This :
Natsu burned Aldoron's Dragon form as well , not just his God Seed form. He was inside Aldoron's belly. That fire you see coming out of Aldoron , that's all Natsu's magic. Natsu did all that damage to Aldoron , Natsu ripped a hole through him , Natsu vaped his body. Suzaku managed just a cut on Human Selene's face. There is leagues difference between them.
And Natsu doesn't need time to go into Dragon Force. He can do it instantly. This isn't Alvarez arc anymore that he needs POF to activate it. Ever since he devoured Ignia's flames he has learnt to instantly transform. Look at how little time it took for Natsu to come out of Aldoron's thicket.
I don't think she bled all that much, from the looks of it, it was just blood spewing out of her from the slash itself, as for her coughing out blood, her stomach was cut, plus, it's not uncommon for characters to cough up blood in anime and be just fine afterwards. Plus, Laxus suffered similar wounds to Selene and he was fine.She was bleeding profusely from that attack, and was spitting blood. That's not something you're going to just get up and shrugg off like nothing
IMO the damage he dealt was greater than against Laxus.I don't think she bled all that much, from the looks of it, it was just blood spewing out of her from the slash itself, as for her coughing out blood, her stomach was cut, plus, it's not uncommon for characters to cough up blood in anime and be just fine afterwards. Plus, Laxus suffered similar wounds to Selene and he was fine.
The slashes that Laxus and Selene suffered were pretty similar, and Laxus was perfectly fine after Erza sliced into him, so, it's not outlandish for Selene to be just fine after suffering her gut wound from Suzaku.
Sure , but the comparison here is to DF Natsu , so Suzaku doing that to a Selene with her guard down doesn't really mean anything when Natsu has fought Aldo in an actual fight.I agree that the attack basically should be treated like it would be an off guard attack.
But how many characters can do such damage to an Acno tier if they catch them off guard? So far, the answer should still be just DF Natsu and Suzaku.
Dimaria vs Brandish wasn't tho. She literally stops time, there is no "defence" that you can put up against it. All attacks used by Dimaria would be like if she caught them off guard, by default.
The thing is, DF Natsu never fought against dragon Aldo.
The same attack used against dragon Aldo directly wouldn't have done much IMO. The reason it blew a hole through dragon Aldo was because the same attack took down Aldo seed, hence all seeds were down by that point. Which means Aldo was dead at that point, and his body at that point merely got reduced to a huge mass of forest, without the inherent durability of "dragon Aldo"
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Well this seems to work based on the character's favoritismWhat I find funny is that in all of the fantasy battles throughout the tournament so far, it seemed like the only thing that people cared about was "feats"...
When we finally get to a canon battle that has been proven through actual feats from the manga itself - all of a sudden, feats are ignored and everything else becomes relevant to the discussion again.
For the record, I only have a single standard and this is as close to a "manga feat" as you will possibly ever get:
And this time, there's absolutely no ambiguity in terms of whether or not Natsu was serious.
Natsu not reaching his full potential does not mean that he wasn't serious.
Suzaku was just fast enough in finishing him off before he could ever unleash his peak power, which is the nature of this tournament.