Voting Round 3 Thorfinn Karlsefni vs. Edward Elric

[Vandred]

Thorfinn Karlsefni Vinland Saga	-	Edward Elric Fullmetal Alchemist

 

[Arjuna]

Thorfinn for me

Sorry Revo

 

[M3J]

Elric, easily.

 

[xi0]

Elric, easily.

You're hatevoting... You didn't even hear arguments, as you'd need it since you know nothing about Thorfinn.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2018, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2018 ---

@revo eats cats, vote Thorfinn

 

[revo]

@revo eats cats, vote Thorfinn

My, my. I would never, never do that

Will start the campaign soon as possible \/

 

[M3J]

You're hatevoting... You didn't even hear arguments, as you'd need it since you know nothing about Thorfinn.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 14, 2018, Original Post Date: Dec 14, 2018 ---

@revo eats cats, vote Thorfinn

where's your argument, then, bitch? Elric has proven his husbando

 

[Bittersweettea]

I will vote for Edward because I plan to support revo until the end! Guys, vote for Edward!

 

[Reebi]

Where are the campaigns???

 

[Brandish μ]

Thorfinn is my type of man, voted his way. Nothing against Ed, he's a good guy too.

 

[Arjuna]

Just an argument Thorfinn will be a good Husbando

He will give birth to the first European child in North America with his waifu Gudrid.

 

[revo]

Previous campaigns
I
II
III

Why is the red blonde a good husbando?

Edward had a very difficult, hard childhood and life

He's a man of life, making his own philosophy and ideas, understanding the pain of the others and showing his compassion

And despite all, he's a great and kind man, who only cares about a having a good life for him and everyone, giving up anything related to power, and beliving in the equality of everyone

He's an intellectual, with a nerdy friki love for science and alchemy, one of the things who hype him the most (but this doesn't quit the privilege he gives to the safety of the people he loves and the rest of the world, who always come first to him).
He loves knowledge and is also a traveler, like Winry said "a man who doesn't do anything is boring" (•ﾟдﾟ•)

But he's also a fighter (who can and will protect you)

He has a deep love for his brother

His mother

His canon waifu

And his kids

He's a little cutie, so he can be the tsundere, dork, adorable husband-type

Or he can end up being a 100% husbando material

Please vote for the Ed \o/

​

 

[Farfalla]

Where are the campaigns???

Shameful campaign beggers Wonder if you guys read every single one of those long ass posts round after round, considering usually a good starting campaign post alrdy gives people a pretty good idea about the character - and a place for you to start guessing about them. No one asks questions about them to help building a judgement afterwards and base a vote. And then people go for looking down on the ones that take a break 'cause structuring thoughts out of the blue and with no guidelines is hard as hell u.ú

 

[xi0]

Yeah, I was expecting more to go off of... some salt and banter. I was very prepared for it, but my matchups so far have been too civil, despite my best efforts...

Well, I'll link to past rounds posts and perhaps I'll find some inspiration for this one too later.

https://mangahelpers.com/forum/posts/4949951/
https://mangahelpers.com/forum/posts/4955726/

 

[Arjuna]

Well i hardly read anyone's campaign

 

[Reebi]

Shameful campaign beggers Wonder if you guys read every single one of those long ass posts round after round, considering usually a good starting campaign post alrdy gives people a pretty good idea about the character - and a place for you to start guessing about them. No one asks questions about them to help building a judgement afterwards and base a vote. And then people go for looking down on the ones that take a break 'cause structuring thoughts out of the blue and with no guidelines is hard as hell u.ú

It doesn’t have to be long, just a couple of photos saying why they make a great husbando. Qualities in a list form is great because it gets right to the point. No one wants to read a novel of their life’s story. I guess what I am looking for is a reason to vote, even if I know the character. I want to be convinced because I am unsure this round.

 

[Elusia]

Shameful campaign beggers Wonder if you guys read every single one of those long ass posts round after round, considering usually a good starting campaign post alrdy gives people a pretty good idea about the character - and a place for you to start guessing about them. No one asks questions about them to help building a judgement afterwards and base a vote. And then people go for looking down on the ones that take a break 'cause structuring thoughts out of the blue and with no guidelines is hard as hell u.ú

I am gonna be the minority of people, but I do read all the campaigns of the nominators and judge them from that plus from what I've heard of them. There are few exceptions if I know both of the characters, then it'll be pretty easy to pick the better one, but I'm mostly doing it because I don't really know them and I want to know more about them.

 

[z.5]

Shameful campaign beggers Wonder if you guys read every single one of those long ass posts round after round, considering usually a good starting campaign post alrdy gives people a pretty good idea about the character - and a place for you to start guessing about them. No one asks questions about them to help building a judgement afterwards and base a vote. And then people go for looking down on the ones that take a break 'cause structuring thoughts out of the blue and with no guidelines is hard as hell u.ú

Yeah, I certainly do.

No campaign, no vote.
... and if your 'campaign' just equates to posting a series of pretty pictures, with no text whatsoever (or fewer words than images), I vote for the other guy.

Words are important - even if I knew both the characters (and thought that one is a right bellend)

 

[xi0]

Words are important - even if I know both the characters (and think one is a right bellend)

Please elaborate on why Ed is a bell-end, please.

 

[z.5]

Please elaborate on why Ed is a bell-end, please.

Oh ho!

But it is not my place to campaign for you - you want some salt, you gotta mine it yourself

 

[xi0]

Oh ho!

But it is not my place to campaign for you - you want some salt, you gotta mine it yourself

Well, it couldn't possibly be Thorfinn, so I'm a bit perplexed...

But fair enough, I guess it might have to remain a mystery