Match - What if National are replayed with the same players but current level? | MangaHelpers



  • Join in and nominate your favorite shows of the summer season 2023!

Match What if National are replayed with the same players but current level?

-Ken-

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
4,026
Reaction score
601
Gender
Male
Country
Thailand
In partifular, I'll like to focus on what people think about Seigaku match against Hyoutei/Rikkai/Shitenhouji.

Here's the relevant number I copy from the wikipedia

Hyoutei
Regional
  • Reserve: Hiyoshi Wakashi 4-6 Echizen Ryoma
  • Singles 1: Atobe Keigo 7-6 (37-35) Tezuka Kunimitsu
  • Singles 2: Akutagawa Jirou 1-6 Fuji Shūsuke
  • Singles 3: Kabaji Munehiro No Game (2-2) Kawamura Takashi
  • Doubles 1: Shishido Ryou/Ootori Chōtarō 6-3 Inui Sadaharu/Kaidō Kaoru
  • Doubles 2: Oshitari Yūshi/Muhaki Gakuto 4-6 Kikumaru Eiji/Momoshiro Takeshi
National
  • Singles 1: Atobe Keigo 6-7 (117-119) Echizen Ryoma
  • Doubles 1: Shishido Ryou/Ootori Choutarou 7-6 (9-7) Ooishi Shuuichirou/Kikumaru Eiji
  • Singles 2: Kabaji Munehiro 6-7 Tezuka Kunimitsu
  • Doubles 2: Mukahi Gakuto/Hiyoshi Wakashi 5-7 Inui Sadaharu/Kaidou Kaoru
  • Singles 3: Oshitari Yuushi 6-4 Momoshiro Takeshi
Rikkai
Regional
  • Singles 1: Sanada Genichirō 5-7 Echizen Ryoma
  • Singles 2: Kirihara Akaya 5-7(Manga) 4-6(Anime) Fuji Shūsuke
  • Singles 3: Yanagi Renji 6-7 (29-31) Inui Sadaharu
  • Doubles 1: Niō Masaharu/Yagyū Hiroshi 6-4 Oishi Shūichiro/Kikumaru Eiji
  • Doubles 2: Marui Bunta/Jackal Kuwahara 6-1(manga) 7-5(anime) Kaidō Kaoru/Momoshiro Takeshi
National
  • Singles 1: Yukimura Seiichi 4-6 Echizen Ryoma
  • Doubles 1: Marui Bunta/Jackal Kuwahara 5-7 Ooishi Shuuichirou/Kikumaru Eiji
  • Singles 2: Niou Masaharu 5-7 Fuji Shuusuke
  • Doubles 2: Yanagi Renji/Kirihara Akaya 5-1 (retired) Inui Sadaharu/Kaidou Kaoru
  • Singles 3: Sanada Genichirou 7-5 Tezuka Kunimitsu

Shitenhoji
National
  • Singles 1: Echizen Ryoma - Tooyama Kintarou
  • Doubles 1: Tezuka Kunimitsu/Inui Sadaharu 6-1 Chitose Senri/Zaizen Hikaru
  • Singles 2: Kawamura Takashi 0-5 (retired) Ishida Gin
  • Doubles 2: Kaidou Kaoru/Momoshiro Takeshi 7-6 (7-5) Hitouji Yuuji/Konjiki Koharu
  • Singles 3: Fuji Shuusuke 6-7 Shiraishi Kuranosuke
Special Match:
Kintarou vs Yukimura
Echizen vs All Past Opponents

I'll post my thoughts soon.

Cheers
 

-Ken-

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 12, 2008
Messages
4,026
Reaction score
601
Gender
Male
Country
Thailand
I'll start with Hyoutei

Regional
Doubles 2: Oshitari Yūshi/Muhaki Gakuto vs Kikumaru Eiji/Momoshiro Takeshi
Oshitari pair should win this time due to Oshitari insane tier boost.

Doubles 1: Shishido Ryou/Ootori Chōtarō vs Inui Sadaharu/Kaidō Kaoru
I don't see silver pair handing laser combo that Yanagi/Akaya isn't able to. Inui and Kaidou should win.

Singles 3: Kabaji Munehiro vs Kawamura Takashi
Funnily enough as both of them are participating against the same 1st stringer, I wouldn't be surprise if this rematch is also a no game.
However, I do think Kawamura may be able to win if he somehow hit that spotlight breaking shot or the shot that break Gin's wrist again.

Singles 2: Akutagawa Jirou vs Fuji Shūsuke
Fuji win, but should be straight 6-0 this time.

Singles 1: Atobe Keigo vs Tezuka Kunimitsu
This happen, and Tezuka win this time.

Reserve: Hiyoshi Wakashi vs Echizen Ryoma
Echizen stomp hard.

National
Singles 3: Oshitari Yuushi vs Momoshiro Takeshi
Oshitari should win due to how much of a fight he give Atobe. Momoshiro did fine against 1st stringer with his BJK but eh, I don't think he can win. He have higher chance of winning the doubles fight above in the Regional because it can be set up for him to hit BJK I supposed.

Doubles 2: Mukahi Gakuto/Hiyoshi Wakashi vs Inui Sadaharu/Kaidou Kaoru
Funnily enough, I think Hiyoshi/Mukahi pair might stand a chance because Hiyoshi apparently got over the stamina problem. However, Inui so fair did beat the 1st stringer which of the highest feats of the 4 so far so I'll give it to Seigaku.

Singles 2: Kabaji Munehiro vs Tezuka Kunimitsu
Tezuka stomp, hard.

Doubles 1: Shishido Ryou/Ootori Choutarou vs Oishi Shuuichirou/Kikumaru Eiji
They couldn't beat Syncho back then and they didn't got any upgrade now. Golden pair should win.

Singles 1: Atobe Keigo vs Echizen Ryoma
Yeah, Ryoma.
 

Ganonslayer101

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2012
Messages
406
Reaction score
135
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Regionals Rikkai
Marui/ Jackal vs Momoshiro/ Kaidou
Their previous strategy can't make it past Wonder Castle but NBJK will shoot through both of them. Momo/ Kaidou wins.

Niou/ Yagyuu vs Oishi/ Kikumaru
Oishi's Territory and Kikumaru's acrobatics reducd the threat of the Curving Laser. Synchro makes up the difference and the Golden Pair wins. Unless Niou decides to unseal his illusions then it's a free 6-0.

Yanagi vs Inui
Yanagi's upgrades were to his doubles skills and Inui was already the stronger player. But Yanagi also improved his rate of collecting data and boosted his desire so i think Yanagi but like their first match, could go either way.

Kirihara vs Fuji
Fuji wins. We saw this one.

Sanada vs Ryoma
Ryoma has an easier time, but will still be put into Match Point because he's doesn't get serious quickly enough.
 

Hardy

Mangahelper
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Mangahelper
Joined
Jun 5, 2012
Messages
10,812
Reaction score
12,925
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
Basque Country
Hyoutei
Regional
  • Reserve: Hiyoshi Wakashi 4-6 Echizen Ryoma
Wanna point out that in the anime Ryoma wins 6-2 iirc.

He stomps 6-0.
  • Singles 1: Atobe Keigo 7-6 (37-35) Tezuka Kunimitsu
Currently Tezuka probably drops a game to Atobe's new serve and then stomps.
  • Singles 2: Akutagawa Jirou 1-6 Fuji Shūsuke
6-0 Fuji. My one hope for jirou was that Konomi would finally give him TnK but he got none of that and Fuji got his own ability to match TnK's boost anyway.
  • Singles 3: Kabaji Munehiro No Game (2-2) Kawamura Takashi
No game again or Kawamura pulls a miracle. Would be hilarious if he does his lucky final hadoukyu, only for Kabaji to copy it perfectly next (and fail cause he's injured or sth).
  • Doubles 1: Shishido Ryou/Ootori Chōtarō 6-3 Inui Sadaharu/Kaidō Kaoru
Really hard for silver to win any game that isn't from an Ootori serve.
  • Doubles 2: Oshitari Yūshi/Muhaki Gakuto 4-6 Kikumaru Eiji/Momoshiro Takeshi
Oshitari is the best player but Gakuto is also the worst one... with all the upgrades Kikumaru got and with NBJK Seigaku should win (unless Yuushi can hit the SSS but that's probably not the case).

National
  • Singles 1: Atobe Keigo 6-7 (117-119) Echizen Ryoma
Ryoma wins comfortably.
  • Doubles 1: Shishido Ryou/Ootori Choutarou 7-6 (9-7) Ooishi Shuuichirou/Kikumaru Eiji
Golden pair wins comfortably since they have synchro.
  • Singles 2: Kabaji Munehiro 6-7 Tezuka Kunimitsu
Oh no not this again. Ideally Tezuka plays this smart and breaks Kabaji's serve and only then he starts using ZSS and wins 6-4 or something. With PIS he loses.
  • Doubles 2: Mukahi Gakuto/Hiyoshi Wakashi 5-7 Inui Sadaharu/Kaidou Kaoru
More interested in Hiyoshi vs Kaidou lol. Seigaku wins I guess.
  • Singles 3: Oshitari Yuushi 6-4 Momoshiro Takeshi
Momo wins unless Yuushi learns the SSS.

Rikkai
Regional
  • Singles 1: Sanada Genichirō 5-7 Echizen Ryoma
Ryoma gets himself to 0-5 trying to cleanly return every single of Sanada's new moves then wins 7 games in a row.
  • Singles 2: Kirihara Akaya 5-7(Manga) 4-6(Anime) Fuji Shūsuke
Both got upgrades to be able tor ally against TnK then got further upgrades. Could go either way imo, Fuji probably wins 7-6 because Akaya faints or sth.
  • Singles 3: Yanagi Renji 6-7 (29-31) Inui Sadaharu
Inui is a singles player sonhe should win again imo.
  • Doubles 1: Niō Masaharu/Yagyū Hiroshi 6-4 Oishi Shūichiro/Kikumaru Eiji
Since then a that has changed for rikkai is that Niou has no illusions and Yagyuu has curved laser combo... I reckon GP wins comfortably this time.
  • Doubles 2: Marui Bunta/Jackal Kuwahara 6-1(manga) 7-5(anime) Kaidō Kaoru/Momoshiro Takeshi
Marui probably won't see as much use for wonder castle when paired with Jackal. BJK and Lasers win this in any case.

National
  • Singles 1: Yukimura Seiichi 4-6 Echizen Ryoma.
Ryoma wins but konomi comes up with a way for it to look close.
  • Doubles 1: Marui Bunta/Jackal Kuwahara 5-7 Ooishi Shuuichirou/Kikumaru Eiji
GP stomp again.
  • Singles 2: Niou Masaharu 5-7 Fuji Shuusuke
Fuji 6-0
  • Doubles 2: Yanagi Renji/Kirihara Akaya 5-1 (retired) Inui Sadaharu/Kaidou Kaoru
Uh, current akaya is way ahead of the rest here I think, and Yanagi's new data and focus on improving his partner should give them the win.
  • Singles 3: Sanada Genichirou 7-5 Tezuka Kunimitsu
Tezuka stomps.

Shitenhoji
National
  • Singles 1: Echizen Ryoma - Tooyama Kintarou
Shiraishi made it easy, Ryoma should win.
  • Doubles 1: Tezuka Kunimitsu/Inui Sadaharu 6-1 Chitose Senri/Zaizen Hikaru
Tezuka Inui walk over them.
  • Singles 2: Kawamura Takashi 0-5 (retired) Ishida Gin
Gin should win.
  • Doubles 2: Kaidou Kaoru/Momoshiro Takeshi 7-6 (7-5) Hitouji Yuuji/Konjiki Koharu
MomoKai stomp
  • Singles 3: Fuji Shuusuke 6-7 Shiraishi Kuranosuke
I think Fuji wins this time around for sure but by little.

Special Match:

Kintarou vs Yukimura
Because it's one set I think I'm leaning on Kin, but in 3 sets I reckon he gets his future stolen and Yukimura wins.

Echizen vs All Past Opponents
Probably beats everyone except Akutsu (if vs Amadeus wasn't a fluke), Tezuka and Tokugawa
 
Last edited:
Top