Voting All-Time Mashima - Best Manga

[Brandish μ]

Which manga by Hiro Mashima is the greatest ever made; the G.O.A.T?

Any manga by Hiro Mashima, completed or ongoing, is eligible. Lets settle the debate once and for all.

Voting Round

• You may vote for One(1) of the options
• This is the final round
• You are permitted to change your selection up to the closing of the round
• You are encouraged to promote/campaign for your selection
• A mod vote will be used to break tie(s)
• The round will be over in 5 days

Voting Round ends 29th June, 2019.

Spoiler: Nominations

Manga	Nominations
Fairy Tail	8​
Rave Master	7​
Edens Zero	6​
Monster Hunter Orage	6​
Fairy Tail Zero	1​
Starbiter Satsuki	1​

 

[Valhalla]

Rave Master

Fairy Tail

EZ is top 3 easily, im liking it more and more by each chapter and i know so does the majority of the community so imma let them nominate it, and i will nominate something else just for sake of variety

Monster Hunter Orage

 

[TimeSpace]

1. Monster Hunter Orage - I just readed it and loved it.

2. Fairy Tail - a mark on it's own

3. Edens Zero - I can't not love this crew.

 

[Brandish μ]

Fairy Tail

 

[Arjuna]

Rave Master

Fairy Tail

EZ is top 3 easily, im liking it more and more by each chapter and i know so does the majority of the community so imma let them nominate it, and i will nominate something else just for sake of variety

Monster Hunter Orage

I will nominate these 3 too.

Great choice Valhalla

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Monster Hunter is awesome. Anyway, does fairy tail zero count separately here or together with fairy tail?

 

[Arjuna]

Monster Hunter is awesome. Anyway, does fairy tail zero count separately here or together with fairy tail?

MAL counts them as different,so don't know how will the Mods count it.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Most sites, not just mal counts them separately. Guess this looks like a job for @Brandish.

 

[Brandish μ]

Most sites, not just mal counts them separately. Guess this looks like a job for @Brandish.

Yes FT Zero counts on its own. MAL is recommended as a reference for Mashima's career.

 

[Kurumi Tokisaki]

Fairy Tail

 

[Cat Sidhe26]

Rave Master

Edens Zero

 

[natsu x777]

Rave Master without a doubt, a masterpiece for me.

Spoiler: 2. The reason why I'm here: Fairy Tail

Spoiler: 3. A short series, but quite good: Monster Hunter Orage

 

[Jammin]

I support Eden's Zero, Fairy Tail, and Rave Master.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

Monster Hunter Orage - to me has the best start of all of Mashima’s series.

Fairy Tail Zero - Even if it doesn’t go far; it was a cute little series and made everyone originally like Mavis more.

Starbiter Satsuki - People were so happy with this one shot; they thought it would eventually be a series; initially everyone said the main was a cross of Natsu’s goofiness with Erza but looking back she looks a bit like a predecessor to maybe Homura.

Although after this point I’m going to be all in for Fairy Tail vs Rave Master. Edens Zero and Monster Hunter Orage haven’t got the length or the depth of the other two yet.

 

[Reebi]

Eden Zero. It maybe only 40+ chapters but it has a solid start and most of the chapters are well done. Rave started cheesy while FT ended rushed and the others are too short to count.

 

[animeangryfan4]

Rave Master: the series that made me udnerstand how HM works
Edens Zero: how can you not love the crew? and the space adventure.
Fairy Tail: the longest, but also taught friendship

 

[Sky]

Edens Zero
Rave (Master)
Monster Hunter Orage

 

[Arjuna]

What I am going to post is my own personal thoughts

Rave Master- This is undisputably the best series that Mashima produced till now,I wish the anime adaptation was better so it became more popular.


Fairy Tail- The first part of the series was very good till Tenrou.After that it fell in quality,still it has its charming quality.


Monster Hunter- Short good series.



Edens Zero- Too boring series,I enjoyed and then it became boring,I dropped and heard good stuff again picked it up and later it became boring again and I permanently dropped it.Too boring for me.It's pretty mediocre series.


So my vote goes to Rave Master.

 

[M3J]

FT is for the most part shit, unfortunately, so not that. Voted Rave Master despite not having read it.

 

[Kurumi Tokisaki]

FT is for the most part shit

You don't believe in Nakama Power?