His candy game performance was impressive too, to be honest The category isn't only about the very first game anyway, you can consider the subsequent few as well.Jojo was GajeelNashi’s second game. The candy game was his first.
(Not) On that note, definitely support @Gryffindor and adding @Lambu for similar reasons
As well as @Belserion, whom I remember seeing as the proudest and scariest townie during her whole initial town streak, and @Crescent Jinx for starting her first game as Doctor and preventing a kill on N1 (on Zasz of all people '3' )