Editing Challenges

[Fnuckale]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

I know a group could use a cleaner as long as he can clean a page per release, so even a week would do as a time limit.

 

[NeoShweaty]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

The pro thing isnt what i am getting at. I mean in order to truely see where everyone is at you have to impose some kind of limit so you can see given a certain amount of time, what can someone get done and then you can go from there. It is a diagostic time limit not a test your skills and see how 1337 you are time limit. I mean it would be the honor system kind of thing but the person would only be hurting himself in the end anyway. I was just a suggestion anyway. Don't mind me.

 

[Fnuckale]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Alright, I won't.

 

[destinator]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Okay got a new question(this pages makes me...)...in the 6th frame there is well what ever it is I cant identify it but I would like to know there is this black structur or is this meant to be complete black? Sorry for this noobish questions but I dont know OP which might help me to come to a conclusion what that is. Btw I started from the beginning again and then messed up everything(the layers) again but wont start it another time just need to learn it...

Here is my current version ( I know it still needs a lot to be done...)

 

[Fnuckale]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

NeoShweaty pointed it out already, yeah, it should be black.

 

[xallisto]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Its Zoro's Bandana isnt it?

 

[NeoShweaty]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

yup

 

[Brede]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Making people understand and appreciate the work of Manga Editors is one of the sideeffects we expect to get from this Academy.

yes it does! at least now i have a better idea (rather than a vague 'its a lot of work') of the time and effort you guys put in FOR FREE to bring us our weekly doses of manga! I cannot but feel a deeper sense of respect and gratitude for all of you![br]Posted on: 30 June 2006, 17:54:16_________________________________________________

Quite frankly the Zoro frame is actually the easiest part and shouldn't take more than 10 minutes.

Bottom line is, this page shouldn't take longer than 1-2 hours.

You're joking right? I don't even know how to begin on that Zoro panel
Q: Do i have to blank out the sound effects as well?

 

[Fnuckale]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Nope, I am not.
And no, you don't.

 

[njt]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - introduction challenge

Wow- that's amazing good job *coming from a n00b though hehe*
(comment on des' page for the challenge)

 

[Brede]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

i handed in my first cleaning 'assignment', posted in my cleaning thread...

 

[Fnuckale]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

If it's the final product you should post it on the Cleaning Challenge #01 thread instead, just like des did.

 

[Jamie]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Not final but:

http://img486.imageshack.us/img486/2111/cleaingpract5gk.gif

Just a note this is my first time cleaning for real. So take it easy. ^_^;

I still have a lot to do.

 

[destinator]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

I really nice how you did that special panel...I really like it and just spotted a error on my try through your version =)

 

[Jamie]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

I really nice how you did that special panel...I really like it and just spotted a error on my try through your version =)

:P Which special panel?
And thank you. ^_^

 

[destinator]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

:P Which special panel?
And thank you. ^_^

7th panel with all the redrawing of the guy there...

 

[Fnuckale]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

Well as long as a clean not on the Cleaning Challenge #1 thread (as in not the discussion thread) I will not be able to judge it :P

 

[Brede]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

@jamie: ooooh! yours look really nice! i like the way you did the Zoro panel in the last row

 

[NeoShweaty]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

fnuck or any one else, how to do turn on and off aliasing for lines?

Also jamie, you didnt finish redrawing zoro or even removing the japanese text completely and you, des and brede (or what he has so far) all didnt redo the lines in the middle panel of the page.

 

[Jamie]

Re: Cleaning Challenge #01 - discussion thread

fnuck or any one else, how to do turn on and off aliasing for lines?

Also jamie, you didnt finish redrawing zoro or even removing the japanese text completely and you, des and brede (or what he has so far) all didnt redo the lines in the middle panel of the page.

I know. It's really hard and time consuming >.<

And I said I wasn't done. And plus I don't think we have to edit sfx. XD