Discussion - Israeli–Palestinian conflict (Recent Developments) | Page 2 | MangaHelpers



  • Join in and nominate your favorite shows of the summer season 2023!

Discussion Israeli–Palestinian conflict (Recent Developments)

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
42,678
Reaction score
21,835
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Eh, I was kinda referring to the hay day of the KKK but it doesn't really matter I guess.

However, that charter is from the 80s. Do we have any proof of them still holding to those ideals? I personally haven't seen anyone point to anything other than that charter for those claims. So I don't know if they still adhere to any of that or not.
Well, even in that scenario the situation is different. KKK was a group that at worst had numerous members and some influence and carried out violence against certain people. Hamas in turn is the actual governing body at gaza. Its one thing to have KKK being the KKK as it was, it is a different story to have it being the governing body (which never happened).

From what I gather they have not actually separated from it. Some within hamas say it no longer represents them and others say it does represent them and stick to it. However considering they do not accept Israel as a state and they have attacked the civilian population at Israel. At the very least it seems like in general they stick to it. I might be wrong on that one, I could use clearer information...
 

DoctorApollo

Artist
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2010
Messages
437
Reaction score
276
Gender
Male
Country
Israel
I just don't know about Hamas not wanting peace. Maybe certain people in the organization or it's head or whatever, but surely those individuals being bombed and killed directly would at least be open to some sort of serious (and by serious I mean Israel will at least have to begin reversing the horrible conditions of Palestinians) peace talks. Maybe I'm wrong, the media in all countries doesn't giver Hamas any real tv time so all we know about them is what others have said. I just find it strange that we say Hamas doesn't want peace but Israel does though both have continued fighting since their existence. To me, Hamas doesn't fill terribly different than your average right-wing militant organization that pops up in nearly every country including the US (I'm thinking the KKK for instance). Though honestly, the KKK has a much more serious history with terrorism than Hamas does.
I'm kinda more familiar with this than you seeing as I live here, so I'll just explain to you a few things you have definitely wrong.

1. I don't want to get into this because neither side is morally right regardless, and killing kids sucks, but it is a definitely proven fact that Hamas uses tactics that are defined as human shields. There is no point where they physically hold the kid in front of them so that the bullet has to go through the kid. No. That's not what they mean when they say human shields. The point is that Hamas chooses to fire rockets directly from urban areas, from inside hospitals/hotels/houses, which means that the IDF is faced with the choice of not returning fire, or returning fire whilst conscious of the fact that it will hit innocent people. The choice Israel ends up making, largely, is to warn the people to get out, and then shoot. This also gives lots of time for the actual terrorists to get out, so it's very problematic. Anyway, you also can't really blame Hamas for doing it. It's a very simple solution: Israel either can't shoot, or shoots and looks really really bad to the International community. In a straight fight, Hamas would never win, they have to do shit like this if they want to live. Eventually, Israel comes to the conclusion that it really can't give that much of a fuck, missiles are being fired at you, you have to fire back at whoever's shooting, no matter where he is. That's all there is to it. I shoot you, you would shoot me back. It's just basic war. It sucks, but you have to remember: this is war. War sucks.

2. Hamas doesn't want "peace" because "peace" isn't good for Hamas. What I mean is that the Gaza strip's state right now is absolute garbage. Israel wants peace because peace is good for Israel. You say that they're both attacking, yes, but Israel is just retaliating. If Hamas shut the fuck up and never did anything again, Israel would never acknowledge it. The reason Israel is heavily biased toward peace and Hamas is biased toward disturbing the status quo is, as I said, the status quo sucks for Palestinians. What we define as "peace" is the Gaza strip living under its current subhuman living conditions, and Israel living as a normal Western country. Basically, imagine I force you to live in my doghouse. That's "peace" that I'm happy with, and you're very pissed about. One day, you come up to me, and start bitching about the fact you live in a doghouse, and I brush you off, so you start throwing rocks at my house to get my attention, doing literally anything just to get me to say, "for fuck's sake, you can come into my house and live in a room next to mine, you don't have to live in a doghouse anymore."

And that's what Hamas ends up doing. They know they have no way of getting Israel's attention, and they're desperate to change their living conditions, so they're intent on forcing change through violence. You also can't really blame them, because they don't have another choice. The problem, though, the biggest problem, is that Israel also doesn't have a choice. Because you see, there is really nothing Israel can do about Gaza. There is no true solution that doesn't compromise Israel's safety, and Israel prioritizes its safety over others' living condition, just as any sane nation should. It's more like I keep you in my doghouse because I know for a fact that you've tried to murder my family in the past, and putting you in my house with me is very problematic.

------------------

also @M3J
The Hamas use innocent citizens as shields, right?

Israel acknowledged this, right? Yet they continue to attack and cause tremendous destruction in an attempt to take out Hamas. There is no excuse for Israel's actions. It's no different from a military force throwing a grenade in building full of hostages just to take out the terrorists when they have other methods. Side with Israel if you want, but you can't defend them lying or causing the deaths of innocent citizens just because Hamas use them as shields.
As I said before, it's true that it's problematic, but you're acting like there is another solution. Israel isn't throwing a grenade in a building full of hostages just because there's terrorists there. It is terrorists, actively firing at you from a room full of hostages. Okay. You need to stop the fire. What is there to do?

1. Volunteer to die because you're a saint and you think your life and your family's life is worth less than the hostages' lives.
2. Shoot indiscriminately and blow the fuck out of that place.
3. Try to ensure the terrorists' death while maintaining as little damage to the hostages as possible, but remain conscious of the fact that you will end up killing some hostages.

This is even more skewed by the fact that largely those hostages aren't really hostages. A large portion of them (I'm not saying all, but a large portion,) aren't there because Hamas are holding guns to their heads, like, "woo fucker, you move from here and I'll kill you, you're my hostage!", they're there because they know they're helping Hamas have a strategic advantage, and they want Hamas to win. They are, like, volunteering hostages, and you can't help but feel less sympathy toward that.

Anyway, Israel also doesn't really lie about its intentions to blow places up. In fact, it warns those places, sometimes days in advance. Israel doesn't claim sainthood, it just claims to be doing the absolute best it can, which is objectively true. Again, I'm not trying to defend the death of innocent people. I'm just trying to say that there are situations in this world where the death of innocent people is unavoidable, and you should be happy to live in such privilege that you will never have to make that decision. We do not have that privilege. Sorry.

------------------

anyway what I'm trying to say is that it's a very complicated issue and Israel aren't saints here, because there's no saints in war, but there is definitely no question that Hamas is a terrorist organization using questionable tactics and indiscriminately killing civilians (and generally failing at that), while Israel is a democratic state doing absolutely everything it can to minimize civilian casualties (and generally failing at that). Israel would not continue fighting a day longer if there was an option for peace, and Hamas would not stop fighting a single day if the current status of their land doesn't change (and it can't, really, as I said: there's no good solutions, no one knows what to do.)
 
Last edited:

Drmke

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jun 22, 2009
Messages
4,224
Reaction score
1,235
Age
32
Gender
Male
Country
Palestine
1. I don't want to get into this because neither side is morally right regardless, and killing kids sucks
I don't feel there is a point is saying much about this. By this point, almost anyone could guess what I'd say here.

The point is that Hamas chooses to fire rockets directly from urban areas, from inside hospitals/hotels/houses, which means that the IDF is faced with the choice of not returning fire, or returning fire whilst conscious of the fact that it will hit innocent people.
There aren't any other areas in the Gaza Strip. It's the has the most concentrated population on the planet. There is nowhere civilians don't live, and the Israeli government is well aware of that.

The choice Israel ends up making, largely, is to warn the people to get out, and then shoot.
Small bombs are literally the warnings given to most of Gaza's residents before their homes are blown away. This is not defensible, and no one in the "Western World" would stand for it.

In a straight fight, Hamas would never win, they have to do shit like this if they want to live. Eventually, Israel comes to the conclusion that it really can't give that much of a fuck, missiles are being fired at you, you have to fire back at whoever's shooting, no matter where he is. That's all there is to it. I shoot you, you would shoot me back. It's just basic war. It sucks, but you have to remember: this is war. War sucks.
Yeah, because they aren't an actual military force. Most of their "members" don't follow any sort of centralized command. Like any "terrorist" organization, they are most a ragtag group of people with completely different motives some of which are malicious and others are simply revenge seekers created during the offensive. And this isn't "I shoot you, you shoot me," it's "I remove you form your home, starve you, beat you, humiliate you then you shoot at me and I send my army." And I'm sure you've seen the videos (I have so I assume you have at least seen something similar) of the anti-Gaza demonstrators in Israel that attack anti-war demonstrators and call for the complete destruction of Gaza. And of course the soldiers purposefully killing children and teenagers taking "selfies" with bombs going off in the back ground while they smile and make jokes.

Obviously this isn't everybody, but it is happening and is definitely not being properly criticized especially considering what Israel is doing. What is happening and has been happening is brutal, systematic apartheid through military force. I could, of course, mention the fact that the UN gave Palestine official recognition a year or two ago so I could easily cite Article 51 of the UN Charter, but I imagine you are already aware of the "right to self-defense."

I also feel like bringing up Netanyahu's comments about having the US and Palestine "wrapped around my fingers." I feel like in a lot of ways my country is in a similar situation in its history, one where it must confront, accept, and change the reality of what it has done to people that never had the means to defend themselves.
 
Top