Voting Round 4 - Koe no Katachi vs. Fullmetal Alchemist | Page 2 | MangaHelpers



  • Join in and nominate your favorite shows of the summer season 2023!

Voting Round 4 Koe no Katachi vs. Fullmetal Alchemist

Who wins?

  • Koe no Katachi

  • Fullmetal Alchemist


The results of this poll are hidden until it is manually edited by the user or site admin.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Purity of Magi

The Witch of Miracles
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Feb 28, 2014
Messages
2,603
Reaction score
19,438
Gender
Male
Country
England
Okay guys, it's time to show churros boy.... I mean Lambu-kun, some gratitude. I will make a huge tl;dr campaign post special for him while you guys are going to be all like; ''wow so sugoi'', ''damn that's actually a lot of things to read'', ''holy shiet did Magi post this? Zomg''. Lambu this is for you. I will give it my all, so prepare yourself!

Guys vote FMA.
Because it's FMA.
Guys vote FMA.
Because it's the best manga.
Guys vote FMA.
Just because.
Guys vote FMA.
You shall not regret! .. at least not now.
Guys vote FMA.
Just saying.




If that's not gonna be the case...

Vote Koe No Katachi.
Thank you.





Your welcome guys.
 

Stormsfury

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
1,044
Reaction score
3,341
Age
27
Gender
Male
Country
United Kingdom
Not even a contest for me. Fullmetal Alchemist gets my vote. I'm still shocked that such a deeply characterised and well developed story is this popular, usually things with great writing like this are passed over for manga with shallow plot but have feels trips since most otaku are probably masochists (I know I am)
 

Anti Hero 3:16

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2017
Messages
588
Reaction score
785
Age
32
Country
United States
FMA all the way, no contest my man edward elric is just too good.
 

Lambu

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2016
Messages
1,610
Reaction score
14,197
Age
26
Country
Spain
Well, to make a spoiler-free campaign is harder than I thought, so I will begin with the psychological aspects of KnK starting with Ishida Shoya's character (the main one in the story) as a pilar to build the points that the manga touches.



The will to live: What to do to get happiness?

Big question, dont you think? This is the very first premise of the manga.

How should we face that fearful and exclusively human sickness that is boredom? Well, this young boy's plan is to throw himself from a bridge... yeah, really. :XD







Ishida is a kid with a lot of energy, he doesn't care about the future because he thinks it only leads to boredom: working, paying your expenses, worrying about stability... he's a child for gods sake! he would better spend his time enjoying life to the maximum. Thats why everyday he would try new things to avoid that awful sensation of routine.
And he is happy like that, his life is very simple with his mother's hairdresser shop and his absent sister,so he manages to keep his friends with him as much as he can.

Though this, of course, wont last forever. There's a moment when the ignorance of childhood starts to fade away and we start thinking about whats coming for us, and thats what happens to Ishida's friends. Little by little they start to take distance from him since they start feeling that thing every young human experiences at some point: the need to mature.



Shoya still doesn't want to give up, he doesn't want to lose to that boring lifestyle thats coming to him, he wants to fight boredom the way he's always done! Why wouldn't his friends understand him? Now he needs something to focus his attention, something to sway away those ghosts that got his friends, he needs something to change the routine-based life thats coming to him.





Bingo...


Bullying: the cruel reality of it and its origin

Some people think the act of taking from others is inherent to our animal nature, I believe this to be true even if we do our best to avoid it with morals and social needs.
The core of bullying its actually simple entertainment, we are inmersed in a world where there are things considered normal or regular so whenever something, or someone, appears breaking that rule it catches our attention with ease.
In the case of KnK, the disability of Shoko Nishimiya is the thing that catches the attention of the class that can only look at her with awe and countless doubts. Its here when the children could decide whether to get to know more about this different person or not but whats clear is that she's weird, like from out of their world. What could be better to kill boredom than someone that breaks with your "canon" of regular person? These are Ishida's thoughts...

One of the best points of Koe no Katachi is that it shows a raw display of bullying and from the perspective of the bully nonetheless. Shoya at first tries to understand how to deal with this "new issue" as she needs a special treatment for various things and she behaves and reacts... differently to many situations, but then discards the possibility of communication for a better option in his eyes: degrade her to a simple "object" to entertain himself.




The manga also shines when showing the other side of the coin, the spectators or "accomplices" that allow this spiral of discrimination. Those are strongly represented by the teacher of the class and later by Ueno, they know there's something wrong with doing all those things but they subconsciously empathize with Ishida's view... Nishimiya is completely alone even if someone tries reaching to her.




Its horrible that, in the end, no one will take responsability for the emotional and psychological damage caused by this problem, even the victims end up believing that if those horrible things happen to them is because its their fault... a tragic thought that may only lead to self-hate and, ultimately, think of ending your own life.

Its certainly a very serious and dark topic but as real and common as day, so seeing it so accurately depicted in a manga shocked me to no extent. The author did an incredible job at showing the horrors of this problem.



Well, this is it for the first insight, I know its a depressing subject to talk about but its absolutely necessary to talk about isolation and its consequences to explain many other interesting points later touched in the manga.
 

Organizized

Pirate King in the North
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Scavenger Hunter Supreme
Joined
Nov 5, 2007
Messages
4,185
Reaction score
21,538
Gender
Male
Country
Sweden
Gonna be honest. Of the two, FMA is definitely my favorite, as great as Koe no Katachi is.

Still, that fact isn’t gonna change just because I vote against it here. And @Lambu deserves more votes for his great campaigning. Really hitting the nail on the head there as to why it’s such a great series.

I like giving an underdog a chance, and when it’s such a great manga which definitely deserves more recognition, I’ve gotta support it. Hopefully if it puts up a good fight against one of the best shonens ever, one or two more people will pick it up, and it’ll be worth it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top