Voting Most Overrated Character

[SirSamuel016]

And the winner is...
​

Natsu Dragneel​

​

In Second Place is Laxus Dreyar AND God Serena

and Third is Erza Scarlet​

Spoiler

Welcome to the Voting Phase for Most Overrated Character[/B]

This thread is for this specific category only, for discussion regarding other categories, please visit their respective category threads. For general information and discussion regarding the awards, kindly visit the 2016 Fairy Tail Awards Info & Discussion Thread.[/CENTER]

Voting Info

• You can vote for FOUR (4) nominees in this category.
• You may change your vote during the voting round.
• This round will determine the winners in all categories.

Voting round spans September 25th to October 2nd, 2016.

Looking forward to your votes. Enjoy the Awards and thanks for participating!

Spoiler: Nominations

1. August
2. Brandish
3. DiMaria Yesta
4. E.N.D
5. Erza Scarlet
6. Gildarts Clive
7. Gray Fullbuster
8. God Serena
9. Hades
10. Happy
11. Hyberion
12. Irene Belserion
13. Jellal Fernandes
14. Jiemma
15. Laxus Dreyar
16. Lucy Heartfilia
17. Natsu Dragneel
18. Warrod
19. Wolfheim

 

[Doughboy]

Erza Scarlet, it is what it is. Likeable but she gets away with too much bullshit

Hades/Precht & Laxus to round it out

 

[Summer]

I nominate Erza Scarlet and Jellal Fernandes .


Erza is cute and has amazing personality but she's not as strong as what people makes it seems like.

Jellal Fernandes is strong but in the current arc, I can't help but think he's overrated.

 

[Hermit]

Master Hades aka Precht Gaebolg, the fight with Hades in Tenrou Island isn't even that good since it's riddled with nakama nonsense

 

[Static]

Natsu Dragneel and Erza Scarlet

 

[MonkeyD-Dragon]

I will nominate Natsu Dragneel

 

[lakhan220]

I nominate

1) JELLAL FERNANDES
2) PRINCESS DIMARIA
3) IRENE BELSERION

 

[Ebony Maw]

I will nominate:

1. Natsu Dragneel
2. Laxus Dreyar
3. Irene Belserion

 

[TeamAcno]

1. Lucy
2. Erza
3. Natsu

 

[M3J]

Natsu by miles

 

[Takuan]

Nobody mentionned him?
August.

Best feat so far is his nuke who couldn't even KO Happy. I'm not impressed.

 

[Spirit]

Natsu
Erza

 

[Code]

Happy (He's LITERALLY indestructible, I'm sorta going basing this off plot armor)
E.N.D (We don't even know how powerful it'll be)
Everyone
Natsu is my bae and he will never be overrated in my eyes!

 

[SirSamuel016]

I support the nomination of Laxus Dreyar, and I will nominate Gildarts Clive and Gray Fullbuster. I definitely think that these guys deserve a mention here seeing as how they're hyped up a lot and maybe a bit too much imo, with some things definitely being overblown.

 

[Brandish μ]

E.N.D as a demon of legend (not Natsu). Jellal, Laxus, Mirajane and Gildarts are overrated a bit too, so I'll go with the initial 2 (bold red).

 

[HereNThere]

Erza- Her shtick got old towards the middle of the series.
Natsu- See Erza.
Irene- She looks like Erza. That's enough for me.

 

[Eternal Dragon Of ChaOZ]

God Serena
Lucy
Jiemma

 

[goldb]

God Serena, though his feat against the wizard saints showed promise, his oneshotting by Acnologia was laughable.

Erza and Natsu

 

[Stormsfury]

Natsu, Jellal and Erza

 

[syx]

I will nominate God Serena from powerlevel POV and Brandish (let the hate/salt begin) from character POV.

God Serena was a character I was really looking forward to see in action. I mean, when he was first introduced in chapter #440, he had this badass intimidating look, giving you the vibe of an endgame Spriggan character. In the end, he just fodderized some old farts who had no feats whatsoever. To top it all, he had the nerve to be cocky enough to try Acnologia, but did let himself get one-shotted instantly. At least dodge the first strike dude... Big disappointment.

Regarding Brandish, I will never get the support or love for her. She is possibly one of the worst characters I have ever seen and I completed Naruto, mind you. She is easily top 10 when it comes to characters who made me facepalm the most. It started with her futile and not thought-out attempt to "negotiate" with August, and ended with her non-existent resolve to decide for the one path she wants to take. Instead, her actions don't make any sense at all and are contradictory, thus leading me to believe that she is rather a badly written character instead of a complex one. Put her clothes on, make her look like Jacob and people would complain about the too much screentime she gets.