Voting Worst She's Erza Moment

[Brandish μ]

Use this thread to vote the Worst She's Erza moment.

	​
No Senses vs Kyouka	-	Broken Bones vs Irene​

Voting rules:

• You are allowed one vote
• You are permitted to change your vote while polls are open
• If there is a tie, a staff pick will break the lock

Voting closes on August 13th, 2017.

Spoiler: Nominations

Broken Bones vs Irene - 18 Nominations
No Senses vs Kyouka - 14 Nominations
Sword Shower vs Acnologia - 6 Nominations
POF vs Azuma - 4 Nominations
Second Origin/Nakagami vs Minerva - 3 Nominations
Stopping punches vs Gray & E.N.D - 2 Nominations
Oneshot vs Aria - 2 Nominations
Stopping Archenemy vs Kagura - 2 Nominations
Willpower vs Neinhart - 1 Nomination

Spoiler: Semifinal 1

Broken Bones vs Irene - 25 votes
POF vs Azuma - 1 vote
Stopping Punches vs Gray& E.N.D - 1 vote

Spoiler: Semifinal 2

No Senses vs Kyouka - 30 votes
Sword Shower vs Acnologia - 11 votes
Second Origin vs Minerva - 3 votes

Please forward any questions to the Awards Info Thread.

 

[sardinestunasalmon]

- Erza smashing Irene's meteor while all her bones were smashed

- Erza defeating Kyouka while all her senses are gone

- Erza vs Azuma: first BS Erza fight for me. The actual fight was good. Erza was swapping armor after armor while fighting Azuma, a thing that was barely used later in the story. But the ending was just really meh..

 

[Takuan]

1) Erza defeating Kyouka with all her sense gone
2) Erza destroying Irene's meteor
3) Erza beating Azuma

Imho, Erza vs Kyouka is by far the worst of all She's Erza moments.

 

[Mohsen]

Is there a fight of Erza that had no bs in it?
It all started with Aria. Mira a rival of Erza says when Aria opens his eyes no one would be able to defeat him. Erza comes and one shots him even though she tanked a jupiter canon a few seconds ago. <not to mention Natsu was getting onwed badly by Aria even though Aria had his eyes closed.

That's the moment where one realized how much Hiro loves Erza and that things will get even more worse in her fights later on. What followed was fights were bs was a synonym for Erza's fights.

 

[Costanza]

Erza's broken bones meteor destroyer
Erza vs kagura
Erza troubling dragon acnologia

 

[Belserion]

Erza slicing the Meteor and Dragon Irene with no bones except that convenient one
Erza banishing Neinharts Historia with just a look
Erza stopping partial END and Devil Slayer Gray with HER BARE HANDS

 

[Crescent Jinx]

^The moment you knew END was never going to fight Acno because Erza had already defeated END.

Nakagami armor.... Erza's feet were crushed but she still beat Minerva.....

Erza one shots the person who beat Makarov - Erza vs Aria.

Hm: Erza putting down Acno/saying Acno was running away from her

 

[Brandish μ]

1) Broken bones leap of Erza vs Irene. In one bound she penetrated a meteor and busted it, then caused more damage to a dragon than the other slayer protagonists combined. Imho, she lied about those broken bones just to make herself look good Lets not forget 4 of Irene's Berserkers were overwhelming Erza.

2) The original She's Erza vs Kyouka. Started the meme, so it is either 1 or 2 all-time. Robbed of her senses. Even the wind hurt her. No matter, she didn't even bother using weapons in this state to defeat her enemy.

3) Raining Swords on Acnologia. This was egregious. Not only is the feat just silly, Erza acted so arrogant during it, and before this she shut every one down when they were wanting to fight Acno.

 

[Anti Hero 3:16]

1) Broken bones leap of Erza vs Irene. In one bound she penetrated a meteor and busted it, then caused more damage to a dragon than the other slayer protagonists combined. Imho, she lied about those broken bones just to make herself look good Lets not forget 4 of Irene's Berserkers were overwhelming Erza.

2) The original She's Erza vs Kyouka. Started the meme, so it is either 1 or 2 all-time. Robbed of her senses. Even the wind hurt her. No matter, she didn't even bother using weapons in this state to defeat her enemy.

3) Raining Swords on Acnologia. This was egregious. Not only is the feat just silly, Erza acted so arrogant during it, and before this she shut every one down when they were wanting to fight Acno.

Even someone like gilgamesh could not take down saber with similar move. I guess gigamesh should take lessons on raining swords from erza sensei. Seriosly the worst moment in FT.

--- Double Post Merged, Jul 25, 2017, Original Post Date: Jul 25, 2017 ---

^The moment you knew END was never going to fight Acno because Erza had already defeated END.

Nakagami armor.... Erza's feet were crushed but she still beat Minerva.....

Erza one shots the person who beat Makarov - Erza vs Aria.

Hm: Erza putting down Acno/saying Acno was running away from her

Well to be honest aria didn't defeat makarov. He was trapped in the setup created by jose.

 

[Star Frost]

Broken bones Erza vs. Irene
No senses Erza vs. Kyouka
Raining swords Erza vs. Acnologia

 

[Nemispelled]

I support Erza beating Kyouka without her senses.


With Erza, taking away her senses won't stop her. It's the reverse.

You got to knock some sense into her for even a remote chance at victory.

 

[Kiki]

Erza Blumenblatting Acnologia in chapter 544

Erza vs Kyouka

 

[XXEliteXXAceXX]

I support:
- Erza Destroying Deus Sema and Slashing Irene

Spoiler

 

[M3J]

Erza destroying the meteor

 

[Kiki]

Voted Broken Bones vs Irene.

I still could understand the Azuma fight. The power Azuma used was supposed to be Fairy Tail's, the power of Sirius Island. As for Stopping Gray and END, there was a distraction like Makarov's Fairy Law etc so it could play a little role in stopping them. Also Erza's hands were burned/cracked.

Broken Bones vs Irene was just.....

 

[Arjuna]

Voted Broken bones too.

This is beyond understanding.

 

[Takuan]

Well imo nothing comes close to Erza beating a strong opponent while all of her sense are stolen away from her. This doesn't even makes sense in the slightest.

But since i can't vote for that, i'm voting for broken bones Erza vs Irene, since this is imo the second worst she's Erza moment. At least she was kinda healthy when stopping END and Gray...

 

[Brandish μ]

Going for Broken Bones easily.

"Prepaaaare Yourself" - is up there for most ridiculous quote too. She didn't even have DSM at that time How did she know she would be able to slash dragon Irene...

 

[Star Frost]

Chose the broken bones Erza vs. Irene. I really don't have any words for that.

 

[Nemispelled]

I'll go with PoF vs. Azuma.

That was the battle that started it all. It was the fight that gave birth to Erza's notorious PoF personality. And it cursed us for the rest of the manga, unfortunately.

 

[Schpittfeuer]

Broken bones hands down.

And Erza stopping Gray and Natsu was cool actually