Theory Arthur's Future

[SkyJockey]

There isn't anything answering because he didn't resist it.

You misunderstood it.

Zeldoris didn't say that he was resisting but that the commandment didn't react to him, meaning that he was an intruder and asked him if he comes to steal property in the castle.

Not according to the page before that page.

 

[sobreno]

Not according to the page before that page.

Which page?

 

[SkyJockey]

Which page?

The page before the one you talked about.

 

[sobreno]

The page before the one you talked about.

I checked again just to be sure and it is still the same page that I am referring

 

[SkyJockey]

I checked again just to be sure and it is still the same page that I am referring

The page before that Zeldoris catches Arthur trying to sneak into a room from behind. The Commandments are automatic curses, so Arthur should have been cursed on the spot.

 

[sobreno]

The page before that Zeldoris catches Arthur trying to sneak into a room from behind. The Commandments are automatic curses, so Arthur should have been cursed on the spot.

The commandment curse anyone who intends to run away from Zeldoris.

He didn't run away on his own and returned his face when Zeldoris said: " who are you "

 

[SkyJockey]

The commandment curse anyone who intends to run away from Zeldoris.

He didn't run away on his own and returned his face when Zeldoris said: " who are you "

That’s incorrect. The Commandment of Piety curses anyone with their back to Zeldoris, as the curse automatically interprets that as “an act of treachery against the Demon King”

Edit: also your interpretation of Zeldoris’ comment of “my commandment didn’t react to you” is strange. Why are are separating into two separate categories of powers? That doesn’t make sense. A commandment doesn’t sense an individual without also activating. It’s not a detector like Hawk’s eye.

 

[Arjuna]

Zeldris himself mentioned his Commandments didn't work on Arthur

Nanatsu no Taizai Chapter 254 Page 11

Read Nanatsu no Taizai Chapter 254 Page 11 Online For Free

mangalife.us

There is nothing complex in it.

 

[sobreno]

Zeldris himself mentioned his Commandments didn't work on Arthur

Nanatsu no Taizai Chapter 254 Page 11

Read Nanatsu no Taizai Chapter 254 Page 11 Online For Free

mangalife.us

There is nothing complex in it.

He said " didn't react ", not didn't work and asked if he was an intruder.

He was previously thinking that he was one of the civilians still in the castle.

 

[SkyJockey]

He said " didn't react ", not didn't work and asked if he was an intruder.

He was previously thinking that he was one of the civilians still in the castle.

A commandment not reacting means it isn’t activating. Again the curses are automatic.

 

[Arjuna]

He said " didn't react ", not didn't work and asked if he was an intruder.

He was previously thinking that he was one of the civilians still in the castle.

"My Commandments didn't react it to you"

Means it met all the conditions to work but it didn't react to Arthur,hence he was shocked.


Sobreno I know you are against Arthur becoming God Tier but let's not deny what is shown in the manga.

 

[sobreno]

A commandment not reacting means it isn’t activating.

It means what I said as the context is clear.

He thought that he was previously under the effect of his commandment as his slave, but didn't react to him, so he switched with the " intruder " scenario.

--- Double Post Merged, Jun 22, 2019, Original Post Date: Jun 22, 2019 ---

"My Commandments didn't react it to you"

Means it met all the conditions to work but it didn't react to Arthur,hence he was shocked.


Sobreno I know you are against Arthur becoming God Tier but let's not deny what is shown in the manga.

Lol, what is the relationship with God Tier?

I was against it when the chapter even appeared last time, you can check it if you want.

 

[SkyJockey]

It means what I said as the context is clear.

He thought that he was previously under the effect of his commandment as his slave, but didn't react to him, so he switched with the " intruder " scenario.

That doesn’t make sense. Arthur met the conditions for the curse.

 

[sobreno]

That doesn’t make sense.

But it is...

How so?

 

[SkyJockey]

But it is...

How so?

Once again, Arthur met the conditions for Piety. He should have been cursed automatically. That is how commandments work.

 

[sobreno]

Once again, Arthur met the conditions for Piety. He should have been cursed automatically. That is how commandments work.

He didn't run away on his own volition, he didn't lol.

 

[SkyJockey]

He didn't run away on his own volition, he didn't lol.

Where was it said that running away was a part of the condition of Piety? Do you have a page, or is that your head canon?

 

[sobreno]

Where was it said that running away was a part of the condition of Piety? Do you have a page, or is that your head canon?

It is for literally all the commandments.

You have to initiate the intent first, then do the act.

If you have zero intention of running away but someone force you to do so against your will, the decree wouldn't affect you.

 

[SkyJockey]

It is for literally all the commandments.

You have to initiate the intent first, then do the act.

If you have zero intention of running away but someone force you to do so against your will, the decree wouldn't affect you.

Running away has nothing to do with Piety. Piety’s trigger is having your back to Zeldoris.

 

[sobreno]

Running away has nothing to do with Piety. Piety’s trigger is having your back to Zeldoris.

Showing your back is synonymous of running away from him, and still, he didn't do it on his own will.

Never forget that the commandment react to the intent first.