Round of 16 Brandish vs. Kiria vs. Minerva

[Brandish μ]

Brandish μ		Kiria		Minerva Orland

Voting Rules:

• This Battle is a 1 vs 1 vs 1.
• You may vote for one character in this fight.
• So you voted early and someone/something changed your mind? You can use the 'Change Vote' option to choose again.

Voting and Discussion ends: August 21th, 2021

 

[Tirl]

Brandish is likely tier+ above them together. So its not even a fight. Don't think Minerva can do anything here except hiding. Kiria needs to strike to use her hax, and Brandish can use her hax at will. So I assume Brandish should win this without any effort

 

[Orphan Prince]

Going with Brandish here, since this isn't a battle royal, Minerva would have to fight one of them, and I don't see her defeating an injured Brandish or Kyria.

I see it going as Minerva hides at the beginning of the battle allowing Brandish and Kyria to fight, using the same tactic as she did against Erza and Kagura in GMG, in which I think Brandish could take Kyria mid diff which leaves Minerva vs injured Brandish, in that case I can see Brandish low-mid diffing at most.

But, yet again I can see Kyria winning via hax, but same could be said for Randi. So, for now unless someone can change my mind. I'm going with Randi.

But, if Minerva decides to join the fight at first then she gets take out by Brandish or Kyria without much effort, still leaving those two to fight.

 

[Sevently]

not fair to put brandish here
brandish >>>> kiria >> minerva

 

[Seven777]

Brandish for some reason thinks that she's powerful, so Kyria beats her easily. Minerva just hangs around til Kyria gets to her

 

[Ronin31]

Minerva hides in another dimension until the end of the battle Brandish vs Kyria. Kyria is faster and more offensive so I give her the win here, perhaps before Brandish can turn into a giant or miniaturizes Kyria.

Then, Kyria takes down Minerva as she is far below in stats now. Both great Erza's ennemies but on different periods.

Kyria has my vote

 

[Vex_Haid]

brandish stomps hard

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 16, 2021, Original Post Date: Aug 16, 2021 ---

Brandish for some reason thinks that she's powerful, so Kyria beats her easily. Minerva just hangs around til Kyria gets to her

pretty sure that the fighters are bloodlusted, they should be since its a tournament, so brandish can just think and kyria turns into a sub-atomic particle gg

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 16, 2021 ---

minerva beats kyria due to bfr GG

 

[grey matter]

Kyria beat x793 Erza with her hax, and has enough stats to give her mid diff.

Kyria and Brandish are both hax, Kyria is faster considering her feats against Erza, so she hax Brandish first.

Minereva isn't gonna beat either of them. Whether she hides or not, she eventually has to show up. She loses low-mid diff to Kyria

 

[Hexbend]

Knowing Kyria she turns Brandish into her pet and wait for Minerva to stomp her too

 

[ShaLIGHTNING]

Brandish and any Spriggan eats them both for breakfast. Minerva gets off'ed first.

Ain't the biggest Brandish fan, but as both Kiria and her are hax players, Brandish would overpower her due to having much more MP (taking portrayal in consideration).

 

[Vex_Haid]

Kyria beat x793 Erza with her hax, and has enough stats to give her mid diff.

Kyria and Brandish are both hax, Kyria is faster considering her feats against Erza, so she hax Brandish first.

Minereva isn't gonna beat either of them. Whether she hides or not, she eventually has to show up. She loses low-mid diff to Kyria

Lol

Kyria got no diffed by a controlled laxus who brandish scales to or is stronger then and we all know that laxus's speed>>>>>>>>>>>>>>kyrias.

i don't see why brandish can't rival laxus in terms of speed since her a.p scales to base natsu

actually nvm idk why i argued that her speed scales to laxus lol, but brandish still wins

 

[Seven777]

brandish stomps hard

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 16, 2021, Original Post Date: Aug 16, 2021 ---

pretty sure that the fighters are bloodlusted, they should be since its a tournament, so brandish can just think and kyria turns into a sub-atomic particle gg

--- Double Post Merged, Aug 16, 2021 ---

minerva beats kyria due to bfr GG

All the better for Kyria to cut her strength.

 

[Vex_Haid]

All the better for Kyria to cut her strength.

if they are bloodlusted then brandish just shrinks her and steps on her or organ busts her lol

 

[Seven777]

if they are bloodlusted then brandish just shrinks her and steps on her or organ busts her lol

Organ bust has shown no combat application. Shrinking Kyria does nothing, Kyria cuts her strength and it's over.

 

[Vex_Haid]

Organ bust has shown no combat application. Shrinking Kyria does nothing, Kyria cuts her strength and it's over.

how is organ bust has no combat application? it literally makes your organs bigger and blows them out of your body

how does shrinking does nothing to kyria? brandish just steps on her

 

[Seven777]

how is organ bust has no combat application? it literally makes your organs bigger and blows them out of your body

how does shrinking does nothing to kyria? brandish just steps on her

She's never shown it in combat or stated to be able to use it in combat, so by default it's a non-factor to me.

Because by the time she does it she'll already be Kyria's dog.

 

[Ronin31]

Because by the time she does it she'll already be Kyria's dog

Yes, but Brandish is familiar with. She already was Aquarius's pet .

 

[Vex_Haid]

She's never shown it in combat or stated to be able to use it in combat, so by default it's a non-factor to me.

Because by the time she does it she'll already be Kyria's dog.

She enlarged natsus tumor, thats a feat if she can do it to tumors then why can't she do it to organs?

nah she just steps on her GG

 

[Seven777]

She enlarged natsus tumor, thats a feat if she can do it to tumors then why can't she do it to organs?

nah she just steps on her GG

Sure, out of combat and after having already shrunk it in the first place. Like I said, no combat application. It's like her stabbing August, means pretty much nothing.

A good way of saying you have no counter to my point.

 

[Orphan Prince]

Kyria got no diffed by a controlled laxus who brandish scales to or is stronger then and we all know that laxus's speed>>>>>>>>>>>>>>kyrias.

i don't see why brandish can't rival laxus in terms of speed since her a.p scales to base natsu

actually nvm idk why i argued that her speed scales to laxus lol, but brandish still wins

Can you show me a scan of Brandish's incredible speed? Or any feats that even puts her anywhere close to Laxus's speed?

how is organ bust has no combat application? it literally makes your organs bigger and blows them out of your body

She enlarged natsus tumor, thats a feat if she can do it to tumors then why can't she do it to organs?

Because she hasn't been shown using it in direct combat, she's only ever used it on those not paying attention to her. Here's a few scans of that Natsu feat.

Spoiler: Brandish expanding Natsu's tumor

As you can see, Natsu was not focusing on her, I wouldn't call that an "in combat feat".

And Dimaria mentioned that she could have expanded Natsu's organs till they bursted, Natsu, who was unconscious, and suggested that she shrink Lucy (who she was fighting) and crush her. Why not suggest her to burst Lucy's organs as well? I do think that Brandish can organ bust as Dimaria would have had to see her do it to suggest it in the first place, and Dimaria is a credible source of information, but, she never said Brandish could do it on an opponent focusing on her.

Spoiler: Dimaria's Statement