Most Overrated Character
H.M.K - Buggy
Nominating Buggy? The problem is that he was never rated high at all, yes he has the potential to become a powerful character for Paradise standards with his DF but his only fans were always those ID escapees.
GiantAlienHamster - Shiki
"His strenght was supposed to be comparable to the likes of Garp, Roger, Sengoku... well, it was not."
In the manga it was or else Marineford wouldn't have ended up as it has and in the anime/movie Luffy had no chance if it wasn't for the use of the natural force, thunder, which wasn't part of his own power. Did you want to see Shiki win in the end, because until that moment he was dominating the rest of the movie.
BlackHair - Big Mam
"Even though she hasn't been properly introduced to the story yet, I believe she will not live up to her status."
Why does her character seem disappointing?[We had this discussion two weeks ago.:P] Because her focus lies on sweets? Luffy's lies on meat, is he disappointing too? You don't expect Charlotte to be high-tier material, but by being a Yonkou that's proven false until shown otherwise Imo. All that rant about herm before we've even seen BigMam in action could make her the most underrated character in future awards.
edit: The rent was directed to everyone.^^ I had mixed feeling about posting here too... I don't expect users except for the regular posters to look into this thread.
another one:
mattiaildivino - Dracule "Hawk-Eye" Mihawk
"don't forget he is just a shichibukai..."
That argument alone is mindblowing. How does it relate to anything, it's a simple title given to pirates who cooperate with the World Government, granting them the freedom of a Bounty Hunter. Another
excerpt from the Mihawk Power Lvl discussion:
"...he should have haki, but it doesn't mean much, he is the strongest swordsman because he is the best one in using swords, but he would be stomped by a lot of other warriors."
We've seen and been proven just how important haki can be, how can you make a statement like that? Oo
His titles says "World's Greatest Swordsman" not strongest and your try argue that he's weaker than Jozu because he deflected a long range attack from a swordman. One would asume that his direct contact attacks would be stronger, the whole argumentation seems flawed to tell the truth.