Reviewer Alliance HQ Thread

[benelori]

The mentioned ideas so far + more
- Art review
- Individual character review
- Team/Group/Oranization review from the story
- Plot review
- Arc review
- Mangaka interpretation (Learn more about the person behind the manga) {Not a Review, but interesting no less}
- Arc theme, symbolism, names & art review (Bleach for example, has a big theme in each arc, current old Germany).

Just brainstormin here.. anyone has more ideas for more potential ideas?
Also should we expand further than reviews? For example, once in a while talk about the mangaka? I'm sure many people could be interested in that, I would :3

All these things are present as templates in this section...check the rules, info and template suggestion threads here in the proofing area or the main manga review section....threads are stuck so they should be visible enough...
Talk about the mangaka can be done as well...I suggest this section: http://mangahelpers.com/forum/forumdisplay.php/917-Authors-Artists

 

[Quantized]

All these things are present as templates in this section...check the rules, info and template suggestion threads here in the proofing area or the main manga review section....threads are stuck so they should be visible enough...
Talk about the mangaka can be done as well...I suggest this section: http://mangahelpers.com/forum/forumdisplay.php/917-Authors-Artists

Selective attention is a powerful thing
On a series note, did not see it no. Pretty sweet post you made there, will be sure to go through it in details

 

[mattiaildivino]

Newbie isn't on the team anymore. As you remember, he had some troubles getting used to our format, so in the end we decided that he would leave.

Anyway, Lasza, danzou, welcome both to the Revier Alliance.

Mattia, you can open a Bleach 485 JR Thread.

oh,so the Team is now made of me,Lazsa,Danzou,saitospike and sometimes The Underscore,right?
anyway,no need to be in a hurry,Bleach chapter didn't come out yesterday...

 

[alphabeta]

oh,so the Team is now made of me,Lazsa,Danzou,saitospike and sometimes The Underscore,right?
anyway,no need to be in a hurry,Bleach chapter didn't come out yesterday...

Yep.

You can always go to the OP of this thread to check the various teams.

---------- Post added at 08:23 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:18 PM ----------

The JR threads are opened beforehand to discuss the various details, e.g. who is going to write what section. So, next time you log on, make a thread.

---------- Post added at 10:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:23 PM ----------

Well, since HxH is getting hiatus'ed again, it's safe to assume that the next series we'll add (in case nothing goes wrong >_>) will be OP and sPOT.

 

[benelori]

Not considering seinen series? Or maybe the new hit shounen Shingeki no Kyoujin? It would be awesome to have another monthly...

 

[alphabeta]

Not considering seinen series? Or maybe the new hit shounen Shingeki no Kyoujin? It would be awesome to have another monthly...

Seinen, right. How could I have forgotten.

I'm not sure that Shingeki has enough posters for a team of reviewers, though I'll have to re-check that.

Out of seinen only Gantz seems suitable now. I think we have enough shounen as of now, so actually Gantz seems more realistic than sPOT.

 

[k-dom]

Btw bene, since you are a global mod, I think it would be interesting to create a review prefix. Not all the forums have their dedicate sub-forum for reviews (only the big 3 if i remember right), and it would be easier to find them if they had a prefix.

Edit : Well actually it does exist already... So I recommend that all those who create the review threads use it, it does not seem the case so far.

 

[benelori]

Btw bene, since you are a global mod, I think it would be interesting to create a review prefix. Not all the forums have their dedicate sub-forum for reviews (only the big 3 if i remember right), and it would be easier to find them if they had a prefix.

Edit : Well actually it does exist already... So I recommend that all those who create the review threads use it, it does not seem the case so far.

When we changed the VBulletin version we should've added the review prefix to all non-Big 3 manga boards...but please PM or post here if a forum doesn't have it

 

[alphabeta]

When we changed the VBulletin version we should've added the review prefix to all non-Big 3 manga boards...but please PM or post here if a forum doesn't have it

sPOT from shounen, plus all 4 seinen sub-sections need a review prefix.

 

[benelori]

sPOT from shounen, plus all 4 seinen sub-sections need a review prefix.

Noted...they will get the prefix once reviews are posted...

 

[mattiaildivino]

a question Captain Alpha,will my team review bleach chapters although The underscore will review them by himself? I'm talking about the weeks The Underscore won't be with us,and will do the job on his own, will there be 2 reviews(ours and his)?

 

[alphabeta]

a question Captain Alpha,will my team review bleach chapters although The underscore will review them by himself? I'm talking about the weeks The Underscore won't be with us,and will do the job on his own, will there be 2 reviews(ours and his)?

Yes, that's the plan.

On a side note, stop calling me captain. It was a nice pun, for once. It doesn't work 24/7.

I don't address bene as "global moderator benelori", either. Though I wonder how he would react to that.

 

[mattiaildivino]

Yes, that's the plan.

On a side note, stop calling me captain. It was a nice pun, for once. It doesn't work 24/7.

I don't address bene as "global moderator benelori", either. Though I wonder how he would react to that.

.

Yet,I wonder how 2 reviews will work.hoping they won't "diminish" each other.I'd prefer to find out a solution to that...

 

[alphabeta]

Yet,I wonder how 2 reviews will work.hoping they won't "diminish" each other.I'd prefer to find out a solution to that...

What do you mean by diminish? The more reviews, the better, no?

 

[mattiaildivino]

What do you mean by diminish? The more reviews, the better, no?

the opposite,imo. if there were 10 reviews,would it be better? reviews are long and need time to be read,a lot of reviews would make people avoid reading all of them. I hope you get what I mean,although I may be wrong.

 

[alphabeta]

10 reviews is overkill, 2-3 reviews is perfectly normal. I don't see why one person should dominate one series all by himself. More reviews = More POVs.

It's the same as if only one person would post in the chapter discussion thread.

---------- Post added at 11:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:07 PM ----------

On a sidenote, I am currently in the process of severly updating the OP. Should be finished in 2-3 days.

 

[kdowns]

You still can call me team leader kdowns

I read sPOT and hxh if member are needed for those.

 

[alphabeta]

You still can call me team leader kdowns

I read sPOT and hxh if member are needed for those.

HxH is getting hiatus'ed again so there can't be any JRs in the first place. We might need a hand at sPOT in the future, though.

 

[mattiaildivino]

Alpha,I see that some of the reviewers will send you their reviewed part. will we do the same thing to you? and if not...will I do the part of uploading the picture?

 

[alphabeta]

Alpha,I see that some of the reviewers will send you their reviewed part. will we do the same thing to you? and if not...will I do the part of uploading the picture?

No need to send me anything. Everything should be posted in the respective JR thread. And usually, it's the captains job to do all the technical stuff, including uploading the panels.

---------- Post added March 20, 2012 at 12:54 AM ---------- Previous post was March 19, 2012 at 08:35 PM ----------

I gathered an OP team (check the OP *OMG, double pun*) and told them to move to this thread. That aside, I also told them that the one in charge are Cez and bene. That's because starting from now they are, in other words, it's them who decide what series to review next, what changes make to the format and what people to recruit/crop.

I'm gonna log off for *insert random two-digit number* of days, so meanwhile, those two will take over.

---------- Post added at 12:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:54 AM ----------

LOL, I never even asked if they wanna accept the job. Such a bad leader I am