Voting Worst She's Erza Moment

[Brandish μ]

Use this thread to vote the Worst She's Erza moment.

	​
No Senses vs Kyouka	-	Broken Bones vs Irene​

Voting rules:

• You are allowed one vote
• You are permitted to change your vote while polls are open
• If there is a tie, a staff pick will break the lock

Voting closes on August 13th, 2017.

Spoiler: Nominations

Broken Bones vs Irene - 18 Nominations
No Senses vs Kyouka - 14 Nominations
Sword Shower vs Acnologia - 6 Nominations
POF vs Azuma - 4 Nominations
Second Origin/Nakagami vs Minerva - 3 Nominations
Stopping punches vs Gray & E.N.D - 2 Nominations
Oneshot vs Aria - 2 Nominations
Stopping Archenemy vs Kagura - 2 Nominations
Willpower vs Neinhart - 1 Nomination

Spoiler: Semifinal 1

Broken Bones vs Irene - 25 votes
POF vs Azuma - 1 vote
Stopping Punches vs Gray& E.N.D - 1 vote

Spoiler: Semifinal 2

No Senses vs Kyouka - 30 votes
Sword Shower vs Acnologia - 11 votes
Second Origin vs Minerva - 3 votes

Please forward any questions to the Awards Info Thread.

 

[Arjuna]

Senses get my vote.

Meteor can be excused on the ground that Erza has strong physicals.

 

[XXEliteXXAceXX]

Voted for Broken Bones vs Irene.

Haha, this was a tough one... I can see why people would vote for No Senses vs Kyôka. But overall, I think Broken Bones vs Irene was worse. The reason being...

• It was longer.
• The PoF speech was cringier.
• Erza was able to propel herself hundreds of meters into the air with hands that she just used to block Natsu and Gray's attack.
• She was able to move despite having most of her bones broken (just as bad as moving without any senses in my opinion).
• She slashed Irene (supposedly one of the strongest Spriggans) out of her dragon form.

Like seriously, it can't get any worse than that...

 

[Otaku-thon]

Voting for Broken Bones Erza vs. Irene, it was at that moment when I thought to myself: I'd rather have someone else do the asspulls instead (Lucy w/ CSK SD)

 

[Reebi]

Senses get my vote.

Meteor can be excused on the ground that Erza has strong physicals.

But a Metor? I may not be into science as much as @upsurge but her body would have become vapour.

 

[Takuan]

But a Metor? I may not be into science as much as @upsurge but her body would have become vapour.

Well in mangas in general, and even more in FT, science barely applies to anything lol

 

[Reebi]

Well in mangas in general, and even more in FT, science barely applies to anything lol

True, but you don't need a B.Sc to know that was BS. .

 

[Luca Blight]

Only reason I don' t find the Erza vs Deus Sema moment as bad as everyone else does is because one can assume Wendy's enchantment had an ongoing effect.

Whereas Sword Shower vs Acnologia, Stopping Punches vs Gray/E.N.D, and No Senses vs Kyouka are inexcusable no matter how you look at.

 

[Reebi]

Only reason I don' t find the Erza vs Deus Sema moment as bad as everyone else does is because one can assume Wendy's enchantment had an ongoing effect.

Whereas Sword Shower vs Acnologia, Stopping Punches vs Gray/E.N.D, and No Senses vs Kyouka are inexcusable no matter how you look at.

In a magical world I can see the sixth sense thing. She also didn't finish her off it was Minerva. Her mind was still working and she's very intuitive.

Sword thing, if it was all her inventory (she has a shit tonnne) and was like Ghilgamesh, I can see slight bruising because Titan Makarov pushed him back and if the speed and distance was right it would cause damage. Also, Erza's sword slice Irene

Those punch stop, well it's Erza and she's like their older sister who will always be stronger.

To me, the most illogical in this universe would be slicing a meteor with broken bones. No swords are that sharp even when the speed it would take she had broken limbs and even getting near one would kill someone based on speed or heat. Also, this wasn't an ordinary meteor, it was a deus one.

 

[Brandish μ]

Broken Bones is worse, just the sheer amount of asspulling + her comments in it.

But I'm voting No Senses. Happy's comment is the clincher. It felt like an insult to readers (not saying it is).

 

[Reebi]

Broken Bones is worse, just the sheer amount of asspulling + her comments in it.

But I'm voting No Senses. Happy's comment is the clincher. It felt like an insult to readers (not saying it is).

Was it only in the anime Happy explains the sixth sense bit?

 

[Brandish μ]

Was it only in the anime Happy explains the sixth sense bit?

Isn't the explanation "because she's Erza"?

 

[Seven777]

As i recall Pantherlily suggest that she might have some sixth battle sense or something, but Happy shuts him down and says its just cause she's Erza. Too bad too, even though it'd be an asspull, a sixth sense developing for a warrior like Erza would be better.

 

[Vici]

It felt like an insult to readers (not saying it is).

It is Honestly Happy comment could be " Screw any explanation swallow this reader " it would be the same..

Isn't the explanation "because she's Erza"?

Yup such details in giving us explanation that we needed in that very moment

Seriously everything would be better than that Hiro could give her new armor that would somehow overcome this and Happy explaining the abilities of the armor but we get what we all saw...

Anyway, I voted for Broken Bones mainly how stupid also that was and even how much bullshit was there afterwards...

This is Erza with Broken Bones ( expect in one arm ) standing up and hugging Wendy with both arms before Wendy asspull that she can heal Erza in that state even if earlier in that Arc she couldn't help her with Injuries from Ajeel/Neinhart and that injuries were smaller